I am 44 years old and my folks built our place on Chappaquiddick back when I was a toddler. Last July on our annual family trip to the Island I stumbled into what turned out to be the workshop of Bob Douglas. The fisherman’s look, along with a Black Dog hat inspired me to ask if he was Mr. Douglas. He was, in fact, and graciously allowed me to introduce him to my family, including my kids, Avery and Ethan, and snap the photo. Several days later we happened into the Poole’s supply shop in Menemsha. The Poole’s fishing hat resting on the head of the fisherman had me inquire, “Could you be Mr. Poole?” I had never met this man either, and with my son next to me and the camera in the car not far away, I just had to ask.

Completing the set at Sandy’s Fish and Chips. — Jeffrey Hill

We’re regulars at Sandy’s fish market, and in case you don’t know, she has the best fish sandwich on the planet. When I told Sandy whom we had recently met, I realized I just had to have her picture to complete the set. Everything is food.

Avery and Ethan discover Bob Douglas at Black Dog. — Jeffrey Hill

— Jeffrey Hill