The Benjamin Fletcher Mayhew house, circa 1786, is listed in the Chilmark historic house registry. The four-bedroom house and guest house sit on over four acres with deeded access to a north shore beach. The antique post and beam home has been meticulously refurbished. Restoration and repairs were done by the former Plimoth Plantation master timber framer Michael Burrey and crew. Replacement beams were hand-hewn and shaped with period tools. Windows are reproduction units with seeded glass.


Address: 1 North Slope Lane, Chilmark

Price: $1,550,000

Neighborhood: Central/Middle Road

Bedrooms: 5

Bathrooms: 3

Living Space: 2,200

Acreage: 4.23

Year Built: 1760/renovated 2009

Water: Well

Sewer: Septic

Listing Agent: Mark Jenkins at 774-263-3196 or; or Bill Rossi at 505-367-2918 at Wallace & Co. Sotheby's.