re_wild_art_fuller_street_beach_091325_013
Proposal will head to town meeting later this month. - Ray Ewing

At the Edgartown annual town meeting on April 14, voters will decide whether to adopt a revision to the town’s shore zone bylaw that could make the approval process for coastal property changes more restrictive.

The bylaw would require shore zone property owners to obtain a special permit from the planning board for any addition or alteration to existing buildings. Town officials said the change would help to better regulate development in some of the town’s most fragile landscapes and give voters more of a say.

“This is not a new regulation,” said building inspector Reade Milne. “This is moving existing regulation from one area to another area.”

The shore zone is made up of land within the town’s coastal district stretching 100 feet inland of beaches, marshes, bluffs, streams and wetlands – excluding the downtown waterfront. It’s part of the district of critical planning concern which is also regulated by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission. 

The town’s current shore zone bylaw allows property owners to add 10 per cent more square footage to any structure with a building permit issued by the building inspector. Proposals also pass through the town’s conservation commission, which judges whether the projects meet the criteria of the Wetlands Protection Act.

This past fall, Ms. Milne approached the planning board seeking revisions to the shore zone bylaw, arguing that it provides little guidance to her on how she should review proposals. She noted that many property owners propose significant changes – such as demolishing an entire wing of their house to build another in a different location – without affecting the total square footage of their property.

“I think that this is more appropriate to be decided by a board through public hearing than just by me alone,” she said.

By passing the changes, the town could have more nuanced decisions on development. Ms. Milne explained that while she can only approve or deny permit applications, the planning board has the authority to issue special permits with conditions.

Town officials will propose an amendment to the warrant article on town meeting floor, changing the wording to allow the building inspector to govern repairs to existing structures. Under the proposed language, the planning board would oversee alterations and additions. Only the amended article was approved by the MVC, which is required for changes to DCPC zoning bylaw, according to planning board member Julia Livingston.

“If the floor amendment doesn’t pass, then we don’t vote on any of it,” Ms. Livingston said.

Ms. Livingston emphasized that the change would give voters more of a say in how shore zone properties are developed.

“It makes more sense, not only to have five people mulling it over, but to have five people who were elected by voters mulling it over,” Ms. Livingston said.

Join the Conversation

3 Comments

  1. Why do voters get a say about my home on my property? This is simply giving more people the power to say ‘no’ to something I want to do with my home. It adds enormous cost, massively extended timelines along with unbelievable stress and frustration for me and my entire family. How many layers of approval are needed, the answer seems always to be “more expensive, time consuming bureaucracy”, a building permit should be all that’s needed. We are the reason there is a housing crisis on island, this type of thing isn’t helping.

  2. I understand being upset by what must feel like a “taking” of property rights by government. That said, this is what you vote for when you elect those who believe that government holds all the answers – one size fits all!

    1. Respectfully, if you read the article, it’s the opposite to ‘one size fits all’: the proposed review would allow for approval with conditions, instead of a flat denial, meaning each proposal gets evaluated individually. It’s always perplexed me that people come here because of the island’s character and natural beauty, then want the right to obliterate the very things that make it a special place. Property rights fanatics mightn’t like it, but the Vineyard is a fragile landscape that needs protection.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *