re_terns_071426_zab2337
A tern colony settles in on Norton Point. - Ray Ewing

A typical summer morning at Norton Point Beach is quiet, but never lonely.

Early risers stroll along the shore, feet swallowed by sand and hair tossed by wind. A bright-beaked oystercatcher loafs by the water while other birds around it peck at the sand, searching for any horseshoe crab eggs bundled beneath. A pair of skimmers coasts above the waves, then dips down with open beaks to glide along the surface. 

But there is one thing at Norton Point that wasn’t there last summer: a gaping breach between the barrier beach and Chappaquiddick. 

The breach formed on New Year’s Day and has acted as an aquatic cut-off ever since, having washed away a portion of beach where Norton Point’s tern population used to build their nests. This disruption stalled shorebird activity and pushed conservation officials to rethink their protection strategies, creating tension between recreational use of the beach and the need to prioritize the species that live there. 

“We lost a substantial amount of habitat,” said Izzy O’Donnell, Edgartown conservation department assistant. 

Terns are site-faithful birds, meaning they return year after year to the place they were born. With their historical nesting site swallowed by the sea, Ms. O’Donnell said it took longer for the birds to settle in this year, and some built their nests too close to the breach, causing them to slide into the ocean. 

The disruption took its toll on the shorebirds, leaving them unprepared to face seasonal threats from predators. Aiming to give them a chance to get their bearings, Edgartown decided to close Norton Point to beachgoers hoping to take their four-wheel drive vehicles out onto the sand. The beach is open, but oversand vehicle travel has been prohibited since June 20th. 

In the meantime, the conservation department has taken new measures to protect shorebirds from predators. 

The conservation department, in collaboration with BiodiversityWorks, recently built low predator fences that deter skunks from venturing farther down the beach into nesting territory, and they also enlisted eighth graders at the Edgartown School to help build tern huts this past winter. The huts, which shelter chicks from avian predators, can be seen scattered across the shore in various colors.

“What I’ve been doing with BiodiversityWorks is trying to focus on how we can best manage the beach to give these birds enough of a buffer to sit on a nest and get through it,” said Ms. O’Donnell. 

The breach helped to cut off skunks from one side of Norton Point, but their tracks are still visible in the sand as they meander the beach, searching for unattended bird eggs to snack on. Even after the eggs hatch, chicks face threats from birds such as harrier hawks and crows. 

“For the birds, it creates this really tough pressure cooker of constantly having to deal with, at the beginning of the season, all these nuisance pests being out on the beach,” Ms. O’Donnell said.

Ms. O’Donnell knows she can’t guarantee every bird’s safety. 

“It’s 50 per cent management, 50 per cent luck,” she said. “I can do everything I can and still have a rogue wave hit the whole beach and wipe everybody out. But it’s trying to give them the best chance.”

Conservation efforts on Norton Point — and across the state — have paid off thus far, Ms. O’Donnell said. The beach is home to all six shorebird species recorded for the state, likely because of its prime feeding position right in front in Katama Bay. Massachusetts at large is considered the “shining star” of shorebird protection among conservation experts, boasting higher reproductive rates than surrounding states. This achievement is double-sided; more successful hatches means more chicks to protect, and closing down the beach to double down on conservation efforts becomes a worthwhile trade.

“That’s a really hard thing to explain to someone who’s just coming to pick up a beach sticker,” said Ms. O’Donnell. 

But the shorebirds’ continued presence on Norton Point is too important to let fall by the wayside. Without them, Ms. O’Donnell explained, the entire beach ecosystem would begin to fray.

“If the birds weren’t here, you’d have a breach every year because the beach wouldn’t be strong,” she said. “You need the birds to lay an egg and to poop and to drop the fish on the ground, because that’s all nutrients going back into the ground, getting the grass to root, holding the sand a little tighter, building the beach a little more.”

Ms. O’Donnell hopes the Vineyard community will rally behind the Edgartown conservation department — and the shorebirds themselves. Supporting protection efforts at Norton Point will grant future generations of Islanders the privilege of existing alongside six unique species of shorebird. 

“I think for our visitors, empathy and understanding and an open mindset is what we need,” she said. “We’re really trying to do right by our community, but also by the birds on the ground.”

Join the Conversation

12 Comments

  1. I would completely disagree with the assumption that if the Shore birds were not there, there would not be a beach. The beach has been there hundreds of thousands of years and has survived. Survived decades of uninterrupted beach travel with four-wheel-drive vehicles and now all of a sudden you keep us out. Because you’re keeping us out it creates more bird habitat and then you keep us out longer. When do people get a chance.

  2. This is out of control with the birds…. They are shutting down beaches for birds? Every year it is longer and more beaches… please the summer is short enough…

    1. I’m not sure what island you live on. Here on MV it’s about the same time of year, every year, the closures happen. At the same beaches. And usually the same grousing happens about now, too.

    2. Kate, I understand your frustration, but we’ve been taking wildlife habitat for generations. These beaches were the birds’ home long before they were ours. Birds play a far greater role in sustaining healthy ecosystems than many people realize.

      We depend on birds more than many people realize. They are part of the intricate web of life that ultimately supports our own existence. We tend to forget that we’re not separate from nature—we depend on birds.

      Sharing the beach for a few weeks each year seems like a small price to pay.

  3. I am uncomfortable with the underlying message in this article that insinuates OSV users & shorebird protections can not coincide without harm. There is a statewide HCP program in place across the commonwealth that has proven a balance between responsible access & shorebird protection is responsible for an increase in successful shorebird production. Edgartown could participate in that program. Access could be improved without harm to shorebird populations. Of course there are times that users must accept conservation closures and reasonable users don’t argue that fact. However this all closed vs all open mentality has been proven not to be the best strategy for both the birds and the users. Also, this article fails to point out that a significant portion of the money spent on shorebird conservation comes directly from the sale of OSV stickers. Balance between responsible access & shorebird protection is in place across the commonwealth and could be in place if Edgartown desires.

  4. These protection efforts for the birds are not “out of control.” They are appropriate and needed. The beach is these birds’ home, and it is our obligation to do what is necessary to help and protect them. The beaches remain open, they are just not open to vehicles. So where is the problem, and since when were vehicles on the beach considered a right, and not a privilege? If you want to be on the beach, please use your feet and walk. Until then, please stop moaning that your rights are being taken away. The birds that depend on the beach for their very existence deserve your consideration…

  5. Thank you Biodiversity Works. Having a larger group of individuals increases the chances of that species survival, and for this they need habitat. We humans have already taken so much.

  6. Has there been any discussion about other predators such as skunks eating the eggs.

  7. This article and the article about the closing of the Tashmoo parking lot for the sake of a single plover chick raise an interesting aspect of bird protection: not the preservation of habitat, but its creation. Nature took away habitat at Norton’s point, and the response to this “disruption” includes all sorts of extraordinary measures to protect the birds from nature’s effects (including the creation of bird housing, the fencing off of predators, etc.). In Tashmoo, a chick ends up in the parking lot and its 15 to 20 spaces are closed to the public — effectively extending the habitat. One wonders if the parking lot has thus been turned into permanent bird habitat, as we learn from this article that terns are “site-faithful.” I’m not sure where the balance between protection and recreation tips inappropriately, but the one-way ratchet of habitat creation seems to put a thumb on the scale.

  8. Why do we come to the Vineyard? I think for most of us, it’s because of the scenic beauty. But all that beauty is interconnected. We’ve destroyed much – the heath hens are gone, algae blooming and clogging from nitrogen from septic systems, eel grass greatly reduced, many fish species drastically reduced and effectively gone (salmon, frost fish, herring, cod), no predators and unchecked deer, knotweed and other introduced species growing everywhere. You can only pull out so many threads until at some point it all falls apart and the reason we come here is gone. Shore birds are an important thread. Let’s keep them. And I agree with John M. – stop moaning about your OSV and get out and walk, you’ll see and learn a lot more.

  9. Tens of thousands of years ago we won the battle of the species against the giant cave bear, giant sloth, and the saber toothed tiger. 5000 years ago we won the battle against the wooly mammoth. 400 years ago we won our battle against the dodo bird and giant rhea. Less than 100 years ago we won the battle against the heath hen. I see a lot of beach here in Katama. Enough beach that we should let the birds win one for once.

  10. Stop meddling with nature… building huts and trying to protect them from natural predators is not the way to do it. Let it be…. Extinction is also a natural occurrence that has been happening since the beginning of life on this planet way before humans.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *