The commission is set to hear new plans on Thursday. - Ray Ewing

Edgartown officials are considering a new proposal to revamp a historic Main street building that will be home to a general store. 

Joseph and Lisa Amato purchased 37 Main street in February, and earlier this month contractor Gerret Conover and designer Sasha Robinson-White laid out plans before the town historic district commission.

Initially built in 1790 as a ship owner’s residence, the building is now home to a pair of retail storefronts. The Amatos are proposing to open up the building into a single, larger retail space, along with a new kitchen area where the general store could sell Island-made products and grab-and-go meals. 

The proposed building would add about 1,600 square feet across the three floors — expanding on each — and then add a wraparound porch at the rear of the building where there would be a takeout window along the existing village green.

The Amatos were met with criticism from the commission and some members of the public about the design during a meeting in August, and returned to the Sept. 3 meeting with new plans that downsized some of the elements. 

“The visible massing is far less,” said Mr. Robinson-White.

Most of the changes were welcomed by the commission, though there were still some worries among members. 

“I think it’s a step in the right direction,” said commission member Ezra Sherman. 

Dormers and the flat roof portion were raised as potential issues for the commission, which is charged with making sure buildings in the historic district stay within the character of the historic downtown. 

Downtown business owner Geno Courtney expressed skepticism that the plan would fit along the green as neatly as the developers said it would. 

“My concern right from the beginning is this wraparound porch,” he said.

The project proposes to have a wraparound porch along the village green. – Courtesy Edgartown

The addition of the wraparound porch will not change the layout of the green, which has a walking path that connects Main street to Peases Point Way, according Mr. Conover. 

“The path does not change and the flow does not change,” he said. 

With the commission still dissatisfied with parts of the plan, the developers said they will consider other options before coming back to the commission on Thursday. 

“We need to consult with the client and see what we can come up with,” Mr. Conover said.

Join the Conversation

12 Comments

  1. It appears that the historic commission is just a little off the mark here. Here an owner wants to make improvements only to be met with resistance by the commission that allows private parking lots to abut the park. Something is not right.

  2. Right off the bat, I have a problem with the wrap around porch facing into the green. The green is a sanctuary away from the businesses on Main Street. It’s a place where people go to sit and relax, and when I’m walking downtown with my grandchildren and they need to burn off a little steam away from the crowded sidewalks and the traffic and grandma needs to sit for a minute, we pop into that Park. Adding a wraparound porch that faces the green essentially turns that green into a commercial area. I’m dead set opposed. That green should remain a sanctuary, a peaceful oasis.

    1. I’m with you Sara, there is enough Edgartown, in Edgartown, the green is a place of peace, not a new venture to be exploited.

  3. With a little research, you’d learn these owners are the most kind, benevolent people you’d ever meet. They’re taking on this project not as a commercial money-maker. But rather to truly give back and improve the town. The green is peaceful and pretty, and also hardly used. That said, this is a small footprint on one side of the green and doesn’t impact the walkways, landscape etc. The project is an innovative way to add yet more charm to an already incredible town, while celebrating local artisans and other businesses by featuring their goods within this general store. There’s literally only upside for the town, visitors, residents and other businesses in town. We should be celebrating this project and accelerating its development.

    1. Well, I am sure that these owners are lovely people, and the park is also lovely. I just adore the thought of one small piece of downtown Edgartown being peaceful, pretty and hardly used!

  4. I think it sounds wonderful….Hoping for a Vermont Contry Store, I know if Mr. Conover is involved it will be terrific. I love the Idea of a wrap around porch. What a wonderful break for all to relax, have a treat and enjoy the park….How can we possible complain….I can’t imagine why anyone would complain…Please all the merchants should take a look at their properties and see how they can improve. My only hope is that it will be open year round….How wonderful….

  5. I haven’t met the new owners but I fully support what they a trying to do to enhance the character of Main Street and the park. For them to take on this project for the benefit of all of us is fantastic. Just think we could have another T-shirt shop or ice cream parlor.
    I vote for their solution and I think it should be fast tracked by the town.

  6. As a lifelong island resident I think the idea is wonderful. The Amatos are lovely people and stewards of the island’s history and the community… this wraparound porch would breathe more life into the green rather than stifle it. There’s also still plenty of space across the street in the green next to the Bookstore for those concerned, and from my understanding the green barely is impacted from the porch. This building is on the verge of severe disrepair..we should be glad that it is going to be spruced up by people with such fabulous taste! From a culinary perspective we cannot ask for better… perhaps the naysayers will feel more amenable to this project when they try the food.

  7. I’m torn – the idea of a counter / window in the back with the porch has appeal, but i fear that the traffic (and litter) it would inevitably bring would compromise the green. I wish the new owners well, but think the town is best without adding commercial traffic to the green.

  8. I’m 100 percent in support of this store, and the owners. This appears to be a very tastefully and thoughtfully crafted project. A general store and prepared food in downtown Edgartown, with a nice relaxed place to eat on the Green? Sounds great. Onwards

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *