With respect to a recent article entitled Plans Emerge for Phillips Hardware Building, the plans for the Phillips Hardware space will take the town in a very wrong direction. I am one of the owners of the National Historic Landmark property at 31 Circuit avenue. We restored the property to its original 1860’s condition and have maintained it for the past 45 years. We care deeply about the wonderful and quaint Victorian character and ambiance of Circuit avenue. It draws many thousands of visitors to the town.
To be clear, we fully support replacing the existing structure and the creation of the much-needed workforce housing proposed. A previous comprehensively developed plan, by the highly regarded Sullivan & Associates, was approved by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission and the zoning board in 2020. It checked all the boxes.
The pending plan is not even close to being a “tweak” of the original design and it unquestionably does not “honor the original building’s history while also blending in with the street and adjacent Campground neighborhood.”
The commission’s own consultant says as much in his report. It is a whole different plan that completely ignores the history and character of the street. It proposes a structure with massing and setbacks that are unprecedented in the 160 years since the first building was erected.
Please review the materials, drawings and photographs on the commission’s website. Once built it is there forever, and a new incompatible precedent will have been created. Let’s preserve the town’s integrity.
Lary Hardoon
Brookline and Edgartown
This article appears in January 30, 2026.
