The family behind plans to build a Victorian-style mixed-use building on Circuit avenue is pushing back against a neighbor’s lawsuit that contests the approvals for the project.
The attorney for Jennifer Pacheco Freeman, whose family owns both the former Phillips Hardware lot and Reliable Market next door, asked the Dukes County Superior Court this month to dismiss the complaint from attorney and neighbor Laurence Hardoon.
Mr. Hardoon filed a lawsuit against the Martha’s Vineyard Commission in May that argued the commission wrongfully approved the Pacheco family’s plan for the Oakwood development. As approved, the project would have two retail shops and two upper floors of apartments. Before being home to Phillips Hardware, the lot was the site of the historic Oakwood hotel.
Mr. Hardoon owns the “arcade” building directly across the street at 31 Circuit avenue, which counts Sharky’s Cantina and a T-shirt shop as tenants. Among Mr. Hardoon’s claims are that the Phillips property owners lacked proper documents and the approval of an architect, and that the project failed to adhere to the style of the historic Victorian hotel that was there many years ago.
In his Nov. 3 answer to Mr. Hardoon’s complaint, Pacheco family attorney Thomas Lesser defended the commission’s decision process and asked the court to throw out the case and restore Ms. Pacheco Freeman’s legal fees back to her.
“The Commission did nothing improper,” the filing reads. “It held lengthy evidentiary hearings, weighed the probable benefits of the proposed DRI against the probable detriments, as it was required to do by statute, and then unanimously approved the project finding that the probable benefits of the [project] … outweighed the probable detriments.”
In an interview, Mr. Lesser said the burden Mr. Hardoon faces to refute the commission’s decision is extremely high. Mr. Lesser does not believe the complaint will warrant a new presentation of evidence in court.
“The commission has a tremendous amount of discretion in matters like this. It held hearings. It hired an expert to review the matter on their behalf…” he said. “It considered all the factors required under the law, and it reached an impartial unanimous decision, which appeared on its face to be unassailable.”
Legal representation for the commission did not respond to a request for comment.
In a statement to the Gazette, Mr. Hardoon said Mr. Lesser’s filing is “nothing unexpected.” He reiterated that, in his view, the commission did not adequately consider the historical elements of the design. He also said he has offered to meet with the owners regarding his own proposal for a building at the Oakwood site, which he claimed was more true to the historic hotel.
“We are long standing neighbors and owners (50+ years) of a Nationally recognized Historic Property that we restored, situated literally across the street,” he wrote. “As the only property nationally so designated on Circuit Avenue, we have a compelling interest in holding the Commission to the statutory standard.”
The court has not assigned a judge to the case or scheduled an initial hearing.
