Last Friday morning, I traveled to Boston to join more than 200 clergy in a time of prayer and action. We gathered in solidarity with Minnesotans who were engaged in a Day of Prayer and Fasting for Truth and Freedom. We also gathered to urge Gov. Maura Healey to take proactive steps to protect the people of Massachusetts from the type of cruelty unfolding in Minneapolis.
I traveled to Boston with Rev. Joanne Hus from the United Methodist Church of Martha’s Vineyard and with the prayers of our Island Clergy Association. Reverend Hus was wearing a sweatshirt adorned with the message “It doesn’t have to be this way.” This was exactly the message I carried with me all day.
In recent weeks, my friends from Minneapolis have posted videos of ICE activity right outside their kitchen windows. They cannot escape the militarized presence. My clergy colleagues are spending all their time and all their discretionary funds on the survival needs of immigrant families, some of whom have barely left their homes in a month. Food is being brought to them so that they do not have to endanger themselves. Rental assistance is provided to those who have missed work. These are not criminals who are hiding. They are people who are afraid of violent arrest, inhumane detention centers, and deportation to countries that are not their own. These are real fears, based on lived experience and factual reports.
It doesn’t have to be this way.
It is not necessary to terrorize entire communities in order to arrest specific criminals. It is not necessary for communities of immigrants, refugees and asylum seekers, as well as communities of color, to live in abject fear or abandon their constitutional rights. It is not necessary to murder people who disagree with you. The communities where ICE has been or is currently operating are telling us that they feel less safe when ICE is present.
As a Christian, I consider myself a follower of The Way, the Way of Jesus. The contrast between our nation’s current immigration policies, this way, and the teachings of Jesus, the Way, could not be starker. In our gospel reading last Sunday, Jesus emboldens his disciples to leave the seashore, their boats and nets, and become fishers of people. He invites them to walk the Way of love, healing, compassion and justice and to let this Way catch the imagination of others.
It pains me every time I read about the immigration enforcement operation unfolding in Maine, which has been cynically dubbed “Operation Catch of the Day.” The present culture of ICE enforcement — entrapping, ensnaring, breaking down doors and catching immigrants, refugees and asylum seekers — cultivates cruelty and is counter to the Way of peace, the Way of human dignity and the Way of justice.
I was so glad to gather with multi-faith religious leaders from across the region, to deepen our relationships with each other, and to strengthen our networks as ICE enforcement activities unfold in Maine. We also shuddered in fear as we pondered the prospect of ICE turning their sights on Massachusetts. We worried over the fate of the thousands of our state’s immigrant residents who are due to lose their Temporary Protected Status on Feb. 3.
This terror is particularly acute for the more than 40,000 Haitian immigrants living in Massachusetts under Temporary Protected Status. U.S. Representative Ayanna Pressley recently put forward a discharge petition to force a House vote on extending the Temporary Protected Status protection for another three years for the nearly 350,000 Haitians in the United States. In a recent press release, Ms. Pressley made clear that health care and elder-care services in our country will be specifically impacted by the loss of Temporary Protected Status. In Massachusetts alone, an estimated 1,400 Haitian health care workers in nursing homes are at risk of deportation.
It does not have to be this way.
The kind of extreme ICE enforcement activities we are bearing witness to undercuts our humanity, fractures our communities and even undermines our economy. But it doesn’t have to be this way. This week I am praying that the tentative exhale that Minnesotans are feeling might be evidence of a crack in this way of doing things and that the Way of peace and justice may blossom and grow.
As I pray so many Sundays, May it be so.
Rev. Cathlin Baker leads the First Congregational Church of West Tisbury.
This article appears in January 30, 2026.

Thank you Cathlin. This really moved me. And it was a comfort to know that you were in Boston. Hoping we will find our Way through this mess.
AMEN!
Clear, careful, and exactly right.
Thank you, Cathlin, again for both talking the talk and walking the walk.
Well said. Thanks Cathlin.
Well said. Thank you for your prayers and support for our state.
Thank you Caithlin and Joanne for representing us in this most important event. “It doesn’t have to be this way” is so important to remember. No matter who you voted for.
My daily prayer is that the leader of this country has an epiphany and reads the Bible instead of selling it.