When I was small, I looked forward to our summers in Falmouth Heights, which is just eight or 10 square blocks and where we could wander and explore in complete safety. It was fronted by a beautiful, calm beach we all enjoyed, and on clear days we could see something out there in the distance.
“Daddy, what is that out there, those cliffs?” I asked.
“It’s Oak Bluffs,” my father said.
“But where is that?”
“Oh, it’s on an Island called Martha’s Vineyard.”
I thought nothing more about it until at about age 12 or 13, one of my mother’s friends, who had a niece my age, said she would bring to the two of us to that Island. We hopped on the boat in Woods Hole and spent the afternoon walking around Vineyard Haven.
“What was that all about?” I thought at the time, not impressed at all, and never even saw the Oak Bluffs my father had mentioned.
Then, when I was 36 years old, I married Arnie Reisman, and we were not welcome at the place where my family was now vacationing because my husband was Jewish.
“Let’s try the Vineyard,” Arnie said. “And if you don’t like it, we will find another place.”
So we traveled over here on a cold, rainy day in March and found a house to rent for July on Middle Road in Chilmark. I was still not impressed but agreed to try it. July finally came, and in just a few days, I loved it.
It was 1983 and the Vineyard was quite a different place — less developed, but always welcoming of everybody, from African Americans to Jews and hippies and anyone else who wanted a more accepting part of Massachusetts. I noticed those differences right away.
In a few years, we bought a tiny house in Menemsha, redid it and loved it for years, until we uprooted ourselves, retired here in 2011, and bought our current house in Vineyard Haven.
In those early years, we thought nothing of using the whole Island! Dinner in Edgartown? Yes, no problem. Restaurants in Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven? Definitely! Traffic was lighter then and the Island had not yet been discovered by the glitterati.
Then Princess Diana vacationed here, then Presidents and others found us. And now we know people in Chilmark who rarely leave up Island all summer.
In all, we spent 29 summers here and 10 additional years as a full-time couple in our Vineyard Haven house. It’s been four years since Arnie died, which means four years of just me in the house.
This Island is still an oasis in a changing and divisive world, and its sense of community remains strong and supportive. And yet, my time here may be coming to an end. I feel the call of the Boston area where I still have family and friends based on a long career in television news there.
I have no firm plans yet, but I hear the echo of my younger self, this time looking out at the mainland: “Daddy, what is that out there?”
Only this time there is no one to show me the way, and it will be up to me to discover the answer.
Paula Lyons lives in Vineyard Haven.
This article appears in May 1, 2026.

Nicely said Paula. Wherever you end up your heart will forever be full of all the wonderful memories. Arnie will be with you.
Yes, there’s so much “out there.” But home feels pretty good.
What a wonderfully thoughtful commentary that reflects so many of the life decisions that each of us comes to in time. Thank you.
Sentimental and courageous. Rock on, Paula! You are an inspiration.
Wonderful story of your life’s journey. Happy memories, too, of shared summers in Menemsha with you and Arnie. Keep on keepin’ on!
I am excited to have you come back to Boston. I will miss coming to see you on the Vineyard as it is true to your heart. I think Arnie and Steve want us to “party on” over here. Love you lots.
Paula, you rock! Just turn the page.