From the May 29, 1942 edition of the Vineyard Gazette:
An old and familiar story was repeated on the Vineyard Tuesday, the one about a carelessly thrown cigarette or match — and as a result 350 acres of some of the most beautiful Edgartown Great Pond country are now a slowly healing, scarred waste. A fortunate direction of wind, combined with a couple of well-planned backfires, prevented the flames from traveling farther.
The fire started along the old wood road to Swan Neck, not more than a quarter mile from Job’s Neck Pond, and, fanned along by a moderate southwest breeze and the draught of its own heat, quickly spread along its path of destruction. The time of its start was set at from 1 to 1:30, and it was reported by several observers, among them the lookout at the reservation fire tower. Chief Frank Norton Jr. of the Edgartown fire department was notified shortly before 2 o’clock, and sent along the forest fire truck and Pumper No. 1. At 3:30 the fire had reached Jayne’s Cove, as far distant as it was to travel, about a mile and a half from the start.
A backfire leading toward Jayne’s Cove, started along an old road, together with the wind, took the flames right to the water. Under other circumstances it might easily have swept by the head of the cove and thence on through to the West Tisbury road and beyond. The wind shifted to the west about 3:30, and watchers at Nashamois Point, across the cove, feared that the flames might lick their way down the pond toward Bold Water. Fortunately this did not happen. The wind a little later backed again to a southerly direction, each time it shifted creating new problems for the fighters.
The fire was under control between 5 and 6 o’clock, but there still remained a lot of patrol duty, extinguishing smoldering brush and grass, and it was 10:30 p.m. when the Edgartown apparatus was put up, and the tired firemen were released. Four men, Elmer Burnham, Leland Searle, Louis Goodwin and Francis Silva, stayed on duty throughout the night, Chief Norton and Deputy William P. Silva made a tour of inspection about 3 a.m.
It was Chief Norton’s opinion that the burned area would have been much larger but for the rain of last weekend. The last bad woods fire in Edgartown that he could remember was six or seven years ago.
The inception of the blaze was on land owned by Edwin T. Smith, although its travel was mainly over property owned by the George D. Flynn Pohogonot estate. In some sections the flames roared high, however, when they had a good start, brush and trees were complete victims. No buildings were destroyed.
Deputy Forest Warden Estey came over from the Cape in a Coast Guard boat to assist. The 350 acre estimate of damage was arrived at after a survey of the burned-over area had been made by Allan Keniston, superintendent of the state reservation, Mr. Estey and Chief Norton.
Assisting the Edgartown apparatus were the Department of Conservation fire truck from the state reservation, a spraying truck from the Francis A. Foster estate, a spraying truck owned by A. L. Cummings, and a trailer pump outfit owned by Alfred Norton. Coast Guardsmen jumped in to help the Edgartown firemen, and in the evening a truck and a detachment from the Peaked Hill army station came to lend their aid.
A coastguardsman, George Fernbacher, was overcome by smoke while fighting the fire, and was taken to the Marine Hospital.
The disaster committee of the Red Cross, acting with the Civilian Defense committee, quickly swung into action, when called upon for food for the fire fighters. This aid was asked at 6:30 and at 7:30 two cars with food were at the scene. In charge of this assistance were Frank Connors, Island chairman of the food division, Red Cross disaster committee, Mrs. William E. Mills, Edgartown chairman of the division, Mrs. Abner L. Braley, chairman of the local Red Cross mobile canteen, and Judge Braley, chairman of Civilian Defense.
The harmony and efficiency displayed by these units of the Red Cross and Civilian Defense working together were described by Mr. Connors with enthusiasm and gratification. “When these units can work together with the efficiency and speed they showed on Tuesday,” said Mr. Connors, “I don’t think anyone need to be concerned about the preparation and distribution of food in time of need.”
Once more a spring fire has caused waste and destruction of many different values — wood, wild life, scenery and human energy. The bill is always larger than anybody knows, because so many of the values are intangible.
Whoever may have started the fire with a carelessly discarded cigarette was violating a state law for which he could be punished, but he was also violating one of the first laws of nature for which all of us are punished in a loss of general wealth and a perversion of those natural conditions under which we ought to be living.
Compiled by Hilary Wallcox
library@vineyardgazette.com
This article appears in May 29, 2026.
