re_aerial_dsc_4203
- Ray Ewing

The housing crisis that plagues us can only be solved with long-term thinking and inventive design. While we’ve done a lot with housing on Martha’s Vineyard the past 40 years, it’s been way too little and far too slow to keep pace with the problem’s acceleration. That’s common knowledge. Now we try to build, build, build to catch up. Here’s a potential Vineyard alternative: a full solution that requires little or no new building.

There are roughly 17,000 existing houses on the Island. About 10,000 of these are occupied for only part of the year. We need about 2,700 more year-round units for working people to call home.

We could try to build those 2,700 units of new housing at the going rate of about $800,000 each. That’s well over $2 billion, and doing so would cause widespread environmental havoc and deeply disrupt the character of our community.

This will never happen. We can’t build our way out of this. But this could happen: we could solve the crisis by reclaiming some of our existing housing stock. Five keys could unlock the puzzle:

1. Purchase permanent deed restrictions from willing property owners who commit to year-round occupancy (no short-term rentals). We’ve already begun to do this. Each costs an average of $150,000. We could create 1,800 new units for roughly $270 million.

2. Many reasonably good houses are being demolished to make way for others. Move, refurbish, and equip these houses with permanent year-round occupancy restrictions. We’ve already begun to do this. Each costs an average of $120,000. We could create 200 new units for roughly $24 million.

3. Help people get into the existing housing market with low interest down payment assistance loans and equip those houses with permanent year-round occupancy restrictions. Each loan costs about $250,000. We could create 300 new units for roughly $75 million.

4. Some of our towns are participating in Lease to Locals. Homeowners are being paid to make their homes available for year-round occupancy on a year-to-year basis. Get 10-year commitments. Each would cost about $100,000. We could create 400 new units for roughly $40 million.

These four keys could provide the 2,700 homes we need for working people who earn up to 240 per cent of the area median income for just over $400 million, less than 20 per cent of the cost of building.

The fifth key? The money to do it.

5. Some of us have been working for six years to convince the state legislature to pass a local option transfer fee of 2 per cent on high-end real estate transfers to fund the Martha’s Vineyard Housing Bank. Eventually this legislation will pass. Projections based on recent and current real estate activity estimate that this mechanism will generate about $12 million a year. Go to ccmvhb.org for more information.

Additionally, our towns could use short-term rental fees and Community Preservation Act funds to augment transfer fee proceeds to buy down units for those with low incomes, and to build when specific circumstances make it the best option (preferably on previously developed land). As they have so generously, private donors and impact investors can continue to supplement by supporting our housing nonprofits, which do their work so well.

In a few decades, our problem could be solved.

This is only a conceptual sketch, an outline of possibilities. Countless details will need solutions. Numbers will change. New ideas will surface. What matters now is getting that fifth key in hand. Once we pass the legislation, we can launch.

Then comes the hard part: banding together as a region — not as separate towns — to spend those funds ingeniously and efficiently. We can do this, without wrecking our Island or breaking the bank.

John Abrams is the founder and president emeritus of South Mountain Com pany. He lives in West Tisbury.

Join the Conversation

8 Comments

  1. John, Thanks for the concise heads up. The 5th Key gets you the boat. Let’s hope the State will help us be the model we can be. Steve

  2. John,
    These are very helpful, creative and achievable ideas. The additional benefit of this decentralized approach is that the additional wastewater and traffic created are spread around the island and become much more manageable.
    In terms of the funding, to me it makes great sense that the high end real estate market, which is responsible for the ever escalating property values that make home ownership for the average person impossible, should be source of funding to make a dent in the problem.

  3. Given John Abrams’s longstanding commitment to the Island and its housing needs, this thoughtful article and its useful ideas deserve serious consideration. But the proposal’s arithmetic depends on thousands of property owners voluntarily participating at the assumed prices. Without evidence that participation on that scale is realistic, it is difficult to regard this as a viable solution to the Island’s housing crisis.

  4. I appreciate reading the numbers. I have always wondered how big the housing shortage really is. A few thoughts:
    1) There is nothing in here that is aimed at possibly reducing demand for year round housing? In my opinion, this is. critical element. A fast ferry would seem to be a thoughtful part of any long-term thinking.
    2) What happens when we come up with 2,700 affordable units? A key driver of capitalism is growth. Businesses would now have enough workers so they will want to grow their businesses, which will require more workers. Not to mention more folks, when they see MV has come more affordable, will want to move here. Won’t we be right back to the same problem within a few short years? If so, what problem have we solved?
    3) Towns using their STR taxes seems like a pipe dream. The towns have quickly relied on these funds for their general expenses and taxes in many towns are already soaring. Wouldn’t taxes soar further? And if towns use funds from their CPA funds (seems like short money), then won’t funds be diverted from other important initiatives?
    4)Finally, the key to funding this (which is taxing some people to pay for others) is the transfer fee that is now being considered by legislators.It is estimated to bring in about $12m/yr. Even is this endeavor was financed, the numbers simply are woefully short.

    In the authors defense (I enjoyed the article), he did say this is just a start. But in the end, I see taxes continuing to soar, the character of the island being destroyed (it is already on its way) and the affordable housing problem really not being solved.

  5. I’m not sure where all the dollars needs to come from to make more properties available for year round rentals. I have mentioned this in other applications and I’ll mention it again. Govenor Healey has passed the AdU bill which helps a bit but there are many secondary units that could be rented if towns would eliminate their restrictions to renting out the house and guest house. I have been asking Tisbury to be proactive in this but they are dragging their feet claiming I’m the first to suggest this. It’s simple: remove restrictions denying owners the ability to rent both assets. If you want, add the restriction that both must be year round rentals. Simple.

  6. This is a well thought out approach. I’ve worked with John in a variety of capacities, and I’ve always admired his passion. The reality is, this is not a problem that is solvable. With that said it doesn’t mean you give up. One of the comments hit the nail on the head growth will continue to move that 2700 number and it will always be well out of reach. Every ounce of legislation, we create moves us closer to a wealthy, enclave and further away from solving any of the problems outlined. One of the biggest steps left off this list is the up Island towns letting go of their 3 acres zoning. Short term rentals are our life blood without them, we will all just go to work for the wealthy and work for less. The dollars that come from short term rental tax below exactly where they’re going, in the general funds. These dollars should continue to be used to offset the operating expenses of our towns, not increase them by adding more houses. If you own a business on Martha’s Vineyard and the cost of buying or renting housing is not built into your business model now that your business is unsustainable and will not continue to survive. It is your responsibility to house your employees that you earn your profits from. The sooner we start saying that in very clear terms, the sooner you will solve this problem. Business owners, love, vacations, boats planes, Second homes and Rolexes what they don’t like is to fund the housing of their employees.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *