Menemsha hills. - Ray Ewing

From the Friday November 18, 1949 edition of the Vineyard Gazette:

Up until the time when Abraham Lincoln set the date for the celebration of Thanksgiving as a national holiday in 1863, people had thanksgiving feasts whenever they happened to feel thankful. With its recognition as a legal holiday, Thanksgiving stopped being primarily a New England festival and became an occasion of great value to the whole nation.

As early as 1864 the Gazette published the following solemn warning as a reminder of the meaning of Thanksgiving:

“Around many well laden tables was found no vacant chair, and as they catered to their craving appetites, we fear that they thought not of the window and orphan whose husband and father went forth that they might sit under their own vine and fig tree unmolested to enjoy each coming Thanksgiving. Awake, sluggish soul and consider from whence are vouchsafed to you so much of the goods of this earth!”

In 1871, the year of the great whaling fleet disaster, in which Massachusetts suffered the heaviest of losses, the governor, William Claflin, issued a proclamation of thanksgiving:

“Sensible of their indebtedness to the goodness of God, the people of the Commonwealth have ever been ready to express their gratitude to Him by public act of worship for all his mercies. We have special cause of thankfulness in that we have been protected during the past year from dreadful diseases, from devastating calamities and popular disturbances, and that our labors have been generously rewarded.

“In accordance therefore with the recommendation of the president to the people of the whole country, I invite the inhabitants of the state to assemble in their usual places of worship on Thursday, the 30th of November next for the purpose of Thanksgiving and praise.”

Even though two ships from Edgartown had been crushed in the ice shortly before reducing the town’s whaling fleet by one-third, there was no grumbling. The proclamation is followed by this editorial:

“This good old day, honored by so many past observances, bringing to mind so many cheerful memories and associated with the recollections of beloved kindred and friends who have passed away has come once more. We may well be thankful for the rich mercies we enjoy, for the bounteous harvests of the year, for national blessings, for the precious joys which cluster around are homes, and while we are thankful, let us not forget to extend the hand to those who are in want and whose homes are unprovided with the comforts and luxuries which all should enjoy on such festive occasions.”

This compares favorably with the Thanksgiving editorial of 1903, in which the emphasis seems to be almost entirely upon food. Various Thanksgiving recipes are given, there is a long description of an early Thanksgiving feat, but it is the food, not the reason for the festival that is described in detail. An editorial reads in part as follows:

“The changing attitude of the American is shown in his increasing willingness to have Thanksgiving come around every few weeks and his reluctance to have a fast day. Even up in New England where fast day was once as regular as feed day, it’s a long time since the church bells have rung the people together to sustain one another through a day of short rations.

“…And so, comparing our lot with a lot of other people’s lots, we take pride to ourselves and satisfaction and eat our annual bird with a light heart and a gravid stomach and are at peace with all the world, for we are feeling a good deal of that world as well as ourselves.”

In the Vineyard Gazette for Nov. 30, 1888, appears the following suggestions:

“What to eat on Thanksgiving.

“Thanksgiving breakfast: coffee, devilled oysters on toast, water cress salad, fried chicken, cream sauce, baked sweet potato, tomato omelette, Malaga grapes.

“Thanksgiving dinner: stewed oysters; broiled smelts, sauce maitre d’hotel; Parisian potatoes; squirrel potpie, hunter’s style; stewed cauliflower; roast turkey; cranberry sauce; celery mayonnaise; fruit cake, lady fingers, pumpkin pie, mince pie, cheese, assorted nuts and fruits.”

Strange as it may seem, there is no mention of supper. There is, however, in the same issue, a fine illustrated advertisement of “caskets, coffins, and burial robes.”

The real feeling of the holiday is perhaps best expressed by an editorial of Edgar Marchant’s, written in 1873, which holds as true today as it did when it was first written:

“Again the smile of Thanksgiving day presents itself and the homes of our land are filled with gladsome voices. This is the day of days and childhood soon learns to hail it with delight while old age finds pulsations of joy at the heart, kindled by old associations. When there were but few holidays in New England, Thanksgiving day came into being, and now that they are multiplied it still holds its place as the greatest and best.”

Compiled by Hilary Wallcox

library@vineyardgazette.com

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *