The Trustees of Reservations will not, for now at least, have to get another special permit to operate their oversand vehicle trails on Cape Pogue.
The question of whether the conservation nonprofit had all of the right approvals from town hall has been a central point in the longrunning battle over the trails, which allow beachgoers, fishermen and others to drive out to some of the Vineyard’s most remote beaches.
The latest clash came up at the Edgartown zoning board of appeals Wednesday, after Chappaquiddick landowner Rick Murray appealed a decision from the town building inspector, Matt Rossi.
In August, a group of Chappy residents asked Mr. Rossi to issue a cease and desist to the Trustees for a lack of a special permit, claiming there was an increased intensity of use over the years that necessitated a new review process.
The Trustees, which manages miles of oversand vehicle trails on Chappaquiddick, received a special permit from the town planning board in the 1990s. But in recent years, town officials and the nonprofit learned that no one had a copy of the permit, sparking more disputes on top of the several lawsuits over the trails.
With no permit in hand, the zoning board ruled in 2024 that the Trustees needed to reapply for a permit with the planning board.
The Trustees was granted a special permit for several of its buildings on Chappaquiddick this past May. But several Chappy residents and even some town officials argued that the Trustees also needed to apply for a permit for the trails.
After hearing from the Chappaquiddick homeowner group, MR. Rossi declined to issue the cease and desist, prompting Mr. Murray’s appeal to the zoning board.
While presenting his case Wednesday, Mr. Murray said he was befuddled by the furor around what he saw as a necessary requirement. He wasn’t disputing if the Trustees should get a permit, just their need to have one for the buildings, as well as the trails.
“The zoning board told the Trustees to reapply for their whole operation on the other side of the Dike Bridge,” he said.
“To me, that’s kind of like me pulling a permit to renovate my bathroom, and then when the town shows up…the town sees that I’d put in an ADU and a pool as well,” Mr. Murray added. “It’s beyond what was permitted.”
The Trustees argued that there was no additional permit needed, recreational uses were exempt, and there was no increase in use of the trails over the years that would require an additional review.
“Documented vehicle counts are similar today to what they were in the 1990s and significantly below the early 2000s,” said Darci Schofield, the Trustees director on the Vineyard.
Oversand vehicle stickers, which signal a four-wheel drive vehicle is allowed on the trails, have dropped from an average of 2,300 permits a year between 1999 and 2005, to 1,311 permits in 2026, according to Ms. Schofield.
She expressed frustration with the continued challenges over the Trustees’s trail network from Chappaquiddick residents.
“Repeatedly relitigating the same activity consumes resources intended for protecting wildlife, restoring habitat, educating children, maintaining public lands and serving this community,” Ms. Schofield said.
For some members of the town zoning and planning board, the issue was black and white. The zoning bylaw requires a permit on Cape Pogue for trails, said zoning board member Robin Bray.
“In 2024, we sent this back to the planning board, and I remember looking at the regulation…that specifically says trails and roads need special permits in the [Cape Pogue district of critical planning,]” she said. “These trails don’t have permits, and what we wanted to do was establish a baseline.”
She believed the building inspector misinterpreted the bylaw.
“The Trustees did not apply as they should have under the bylaw for trails and for vehicles that use those trails,” Ms. Bray said.
Julia Livingston, a member of the planning board, echoed a similar sentiment.
“The Trustees are required to have a special permit for any ‘quote unquote’ development, and development is specifically defined to include any change in the intensity of use of land,” she said.
Because there was never a permit, any change since 1990 would require review.
“It’s not complicated,” she said. “They need to have a special permit as a baseline for going forward.”
The majority, however, wasn’t inclined to reopen the review process.
Zoning board member Pam Dolby backed the building inspector’s decision and said that if there was an issue with the special permit granted by the planning board, it should have been appealed to the planning board.
“This issue has been before state agencies, local agencies; hours, months, years have gone into this,” she said. “This is a dispute that is not our issue…I’m not going to sit and research all of these legal decisions.”
The board ended up voting 4-1 to support the building inspector’s decision, with Ms. Bray as the lone no vote.
Board chair Martin (Skip) Tomassian was not in favor of overturning the building inspector’s decision, though he said he understood the points about regulations made by Ms. Bray.
He wasn’t sure how to resolve the ongoing disputes over the trails between the Trustees and landowners, but said that Mother Nature may take care of things herself on the narrow barrier beach.
“I don’t disagree with anything you said, Robin,” he said. “The question is, how in God’s name do we make it work? I don’t know…Maybe we should all go to church and pray for more beach because that keeps disappearing.”
This article appears in November 20 2026.

Julia Livingston says the bylaw requires a special permit for “development,” including a change in the intensity of land use. Robin Bray says the Cape Pogue rules specifically require permits for trails and roads. The Trustees cite vehicle counts and sticker sales to argue that use has not increased. Even if today’s traffic is lower than it was in the early 2000s, that doesn’t answer whether the trails need a permit under the bylaw.
In 2024, the zoning board directed the Trustees to reapply for a permit. The Trustees later received approval for several buildings, while the question of the trails remained. Now the board has voted 4–1 to uphold the building inspector’s decision not to require a trail permit.
The chair said he didn’t disagree with Ms. Bray, but wondered how to make it work. A permit requirement can’t depend on how inconvenient it is to enforce. People here seem to write their own rules, then decide when those rules apply. If this is how Edgartown handles its zoning bylaw, why should anyone believe the rules apply equally to everyone?
The landowners claims of environmental concern are so transparent. Their permitted and unpermitted building, septic discharge and landscaping are completely detrimental to the entire ecosystem. The area should be seized by eminent domain and restored to its natural habitat. The houses should be dismantled with only the lighthouse and an environmental center, available to all to enjoy the area’s beauty.
Eminent domain is the answer to this ongoing dispute. At a minimum, eminent domain can be used to ensure continued access to the public land. Going further, eminent domain can be used to take the developed land and return it to its natural state to ensure protection of the area and public access to all areas.