Island health boards are urging a newly aggressive approach to combating Lyme disease, proposing a five-year comprehensive study that would examine, among other things, drastically reducing the Island’s deer population.

The Vineyard study would piggyback off a recent report from the Nantucket Tick-Borne Disease Committee, which argues for culling its herd of approximately 2,500 deer to 500 or fewer animals, a process the state Division of Fisheries and Wildlife expects to take roughly a decade.

Edgartown health agent Matt Poole, who recently appeared before the all-Island selectmen to ask for their support on the study, said deer management will be a crucial component in any serious effort to tackle Lyme disease.

“It’s the most controversial piece, but I think it’s really clear that as long as there are large numbers of deer there’s going to be a high incidence of Lyme,” he said in an interview at his office in the Edgartown town hall this week.

In the coming months the boards of health are expected to apply for state grant money to carry out the research.

The effort to produce the comprehensive Vineyard tick study is being led by Michael Loberg of the Tisbury board of health and will synthesize existing Island data on the disease, including a 2008 Centers for Disease Control (CDC) study in Aquinnah, gather more epidemiological data where appropriate, and borrow heavily from the Nantucket study.

The impetus behind the effort came from several public discussions on proposed uses of community benefits grant money that will be made available by the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital this fall through the Department of Public Health. In those discussions Lyme disease was continually singled out by Islanders as a problem requiring additional resources.

“At these meetings Lyme kept coming up to the point where someone said, we’ve got to take this on,” Mr. Poole said. “We can’t dodge this any longer.”

The Island boards of health hope that their proposed study will attract further grant money from the CDC and National Institutes of Health to study Lyme. The disease, caused by the transmission of the bacteria Borrelia burgdorferi from black-legged or deer ticks, is the most common vector-borne disease in America. Although it can be treated effectively with antibiotics, if left untreated Lyme can lead to arthritis as well as neurological and cardiovascular problems weeks to months after transmission. Along with other tick-borne illnesses, such as babesiosis and ehrlichiosis, Lyme disease is believed to have reached epidemic levels here some years ago. The bacterial disease is so familiar to many Islanders that its prevalence may now be under-reported or treated informally.

Mr. Poole sees the study as a first step in getting a handle on just how serious the problem is.

“I’m from a family of five,” he told the all-Island selectmen. “Four of us have been treated for Lyme, and I suspect if you go around the table that many of us have either personally been treated for it or we know many people who have. To date we’ve been very passive about living with Lyme and we need to attack it with a much more aggressive process than we have.”

What that aggressive process looks like has already been largely sketched out by Nantucket, whose tick-borne disease committee finished a comprehensive report in November. The report, which Mr. Poole presented to the selectmen, identifies a number of strategies to combat the abundance of the disease-carrying ticks, but one stands out as the most effective: an aggressive campaign to reduce the Island deer herd.

For years Vineyard hunters have pleaded for a longer hunting season but the recommendations of the Nantucket study go even further, advocating, if necessary, a team of professional sharpshooters to help eliminate the animals in order to reach acceptable levels. It’s method that has already been employed in some communities overrun with deer.

The Massachusetts Department of Fish and Wildlife estimates the number of deer on the Vineyard at 50 deer per square mile, though some put the figure even higher. The Nantucket report calls for a reduction over several years to fewer than 10 deer per square mile. As the report says, “Deer density, tick levels and human disease incidence are directly linked.”

Any program to thin the herd on the Vineyard would require killing thousands of deer, but the effort would not be unprecedented. At Great Island in West Yarmouth the herd was reduced to fewer than six deer per square mile, from 30 to 50 per square mile. And Monhegan Island in Maine went a step further, eradicating its entire deer herd in three seasons from 1996 to 1999.

Unsurprisingly, the incidence of tick-borne disease was drastically reduced. To achieve its own population goals Nantucket aims to harvest 35 per cent of the deer herd every season for 10 to 12 years.

At the all-Island selectmen’s meeting Mr. Poole advocated a similar reduction.

Other preventive measures against Lyme disease discussed in the Nantucket report, including a Noah’s Ark-style relocation of the animals and a comprehensive birth control program, have proven either less successful or less practical. Efforts to reduce the population of white-footed mice have proved similarly problematic.

One program often advocated by animal lovers is the so-called Four Poster device which works by rubbing permethrin, a tick-killing substance (or acaricide), on the head, neck and ears of the animal while it feeds on a baited bin of corn. The downside of this approach is twofold: the corn can attract rodents, and permethrin is a neurotoxin that is extremely toxic to marine life. On an ecologically sensitive Island, it poses obvious problems but the Nantucket report argues that it should play at least a part in any tick reduction strategy.

About its principal recommendation, the Nantucket report acknowledges the potential for controversy, noting, “Long-term community support must be measured and obtained before starting any reduction strategy”.

For Mr. Poole the choice is simple, “We’ve got to reduce the herd.”

 

Gazette reporter Remy Tumin contributed to this story.

Join the Conversation

7 Comments

  1. Why wait for a five-year study to confirm what is already obvious? The deer population is responsible for the ticks that carry Lyme disease. In five years, many more people will become infected, so extermination of the deer should begin immediately. This would also help reduce the number of auto accidents caused by deer.

  2. Lyme disease has touched my family personally as it has many others on the island (and off). I have a cousin who was infected early when not much was known about the disease. He is living in Northern Maine where deer ticks can’t survive, but he’s living with a debilitating disease that at times has caused him numerous life-threatening complications. Two young nieces have undergone extensive drug intervention to fight the effects of the disease – it took over a month in both cases to get a clean bill of health. I can go on and on. If anyone on the island can show me, or demonstrate the actual benefit of having a lyme infested deer population I would like to hear it (or see it). I am for a 50% reduction in the deer population every year until the herd is down to a satisfactory level, or lyme disease on our island has been eradicated. Our friends and family on the mainland wished they had the option we as Vineyarders have. In the mean time, there is open season 12 months out of the year on my property in West Tisbury where the deer are bountiful if there are any hunters that want to set up a tree stand. Thank you Mr. Poole for your intiative and good luck on the study Mr. Loberg!

  3. Deer are not the problem. Reducing the herd isn’t the problem. TICKS & INNORANCE is the problem.

    Ticks ride on birds, mice, rats, rabbits, coons…you name it, they are on it. They don’t know state or county boundaries. They love to piggy-back on geese who migrate south & west. They like to walk around your backyard, in all 50 states, & latch onto your leg when you least expect it. Yep, deer aren’t the problem.

    Ignorance speaks for itself. Until Borrelia Burgdorfer (Lyme) is recognized for what it REALLY is (a long term chronic illness not easily cured) your going to continue to see cases increase, no matter if you kill the whole deer herd or not.

    It won’t work.

  4. How sad to choose sharpshooting thousands of beautiful, peaceful animals over humane relocation or birth control. Is that the best you can do?

  5. The deer population is not responsible for Lyme — white-footed mice are responsible. Birds and other animals transport it further. Killing all the deer will not help.

    We really need education!

  6. I would let science answer the question. You can reduce the herd and then make a judgment as to whether it is effective or not. If it is not, than the population will just increase again. Deer are part of the natural population of animals that exist here, they are out of balance in number. Populations of fifty per square mile impact other plant and animal species in a negative manner, reducing total biodiversity. It is a twofold problem in terms of balance. The ever increasing suburbanization of the Vineyard has limited hunting and the lack of natural predators to keep them in check. Deer have plenty of natural areas to exist in, but the lack of hunting access has them overabundant in these areas. Observing and looking at natural plant populations that drive ecosystem health, it is readily apparent that over browsing of deer is reducing forest health. Why does that matter? The plant-animal food web when functioning in balance allows for the greatest diversity of species. This illustrates the co-dependency of all animal groups with each other. When one group has exceedingly high populations others are diminished, some go locally extinct. I think it is very worthwhile to address this issue with science, observe and record data to answer the question. There is no doubt the Vineyard is a unique and beautiful place. However, it is a mistake to think that this problem is unique to the Vineyard or Nantucket. It is critical that it is looked at and examined by reviewing what other communities have done, and the effectiveness of their actions. This is an opportunity to address a significant human health issue but also natural ecosystem health. After all, they both support one another.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *