image_2-7-26_at_1
The building design is modeled after the former Oakwood Hotel. - Courtesy of MVC

The Martha’s Vineyard Commission has closed its public hearing on redevelopment plans for the vacant Phillips Hardware building at 30 Circuit avenue in Oak Bluffs, after more than an hour and a half of testimony Thursday night.

The Pacheco family, whose limited liability company owns Reliable Market and purchased the next-door Phillips property in  2022, is seeking to demolish the vacant, brick-fronted building and replace it with a modular structure holding two retail establishments at street level and 10 walk-up apartments, totaling 12 bedrooms, on two upper floors.

The project is known as Oakwood, after a 19th-century cottage hotel that became the Phillips building.

In 2016, the MVC approved a similar proposal from the previous owners with a design by architect Chuck Sullivan that would have used traditional construction techniques.

The new design, by Scotty Estacio, has a flatter roofline with mansard towers replacing the double gambrel roof approved in 2016. 

Architectural historian Eric Dray, a consultant for the commission, said Mr. Estacio’s design has been significantly improved from a version submitted last year.

But it still falls short of meeting the MVC’s requirement that buildings replacing demolitions should reflect both the surrounding area and the demolished structures, he said.

“It’s not quite there yet,” said Mr. Dray, noting that the two towers are shaped differently from the single tower that once topped part of the original building.

A nearby Circuit avenue property owner also challenged Mr. Estacio’s design.

“[It] essentially ignores 160 years of history,” said Larry Hardoon, who owns the 1870s-era Arcade building at 31 Circuit avenue.

Mr. Hardoon called for a return to the approved 2016 plan by Mr. Sullivan.

“It checks all the boxes. It is a refined design that everyone supported… and it is really unfortunate that it was not built,” he said.

Jennifer Pacheco Freeman told commissioners Thursday that her family is pursuing modular construction for financial reasons.

“We’ve spent all the family money. Now we have to go to the bank,” she said.

Traditional, stick-built construction would cost far more than the family is willing to borrow, Ms. Pacheco Freeman said.

Two Oak Bluffs restaurant owners also spoke Thursday in support of the Pachecos’ plan for the building, saying it would help reverse a business downturn in the Circuit avenue area.

“We still haven’t fully recovered from Covid. We’ve had lean years, the past couple of years,” said Bill Giordano, whose family owns the seasonal Giordano’s eatery.

New retailers at the former Phillips site would bring more traffic to the street, Mr. Giordano said.

“Not having something there, I think really hurts… not just us, but a lot of different businesses,” he said.

Bill Honeycutt, who owns Offshore Ale Company on Kennebec avenue with his wife Sue, agreed.

“We’re a year-round business, and we desperately need traffic generators,” he said.

“Oak Bluffs is really hurting at this point,” said Mr. Honeycutt, who also praised Mr. Estacio’s Victorian-inspired design.

“This building, in our opinion, is a beautiful building,” he said.

Commissioners advised Ms. Pacheco Freeman, Mr. Estacio and builder Michael Fletcher that the approval process, including town permitting, likely would not allow construction to begin before the Oak Bluffs summer building moratorium goes into effect Memorial Day weekend.

The commission agreed to keep the written record open until noon Monday, before a follow-up meeting between the applicants and the MVC’s land use planning committee to iron out details.

The date for deliberations by the full commission has not yet been announced.

In other business Thursday, commissioners declined to take up a referral from West Tisbury regarding a taller cell phone tower, leaving it for town officials to decide, and denied an application for a guest house in Chilmark.

The next Martha’s Vineyard Commission meeting is Feb. 12 at 6:30 p.m., when commissioners are scheduled to continue their public hearing on the proposed Katama Meadows subdivision in Edgartown.

Join the Conversation

7 Comments

  1. I think it’s a great project but since all the other permits expired and with change of lots of the design the planning boards special permit must need to be renewed as well

  2. Wow, absolutely perfect! As I will see the back from my house I hope it has some architectural interest too. Great addition to our downtown!

  3. This design would make a very attractive addition to Circuit Ave.
    I think these commissions get a little too picky sometimes.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *