jsp-grace-palmer
After a day of work as field manager of Morning Glory Farm, Grace Palmer has a quiet place of her own to come home to. - Jeanna Shepard

In her 1929 essay “A Room of One’s Own,” Virginia Woolf argues that a woman’s ability to succeed as a writer hinges on access to a private, comfortable space in which to create and live. On Martha’s Vineyard, an Island with a worsening housing crisis, the connection between stable housing and prosperity transcends gender and occupation.

With homeownership and even renting year-round out of the question for a large group of Islanders, it’s not always possible to secure the kind of room Woolf describes. But 23-year-old Vineyarder Grace Palmer has managed to find it in the form of a guest house on her grandparents’ Vineyard property.

Grace, the field manager at Morning Glory Farm in Edgartown, is part of a growing group of Islanders who take up primary residence in guest houses or accessory dwelling units (ADUs), which are secondary structures on residential properties. It’s a strategy many Islanders are embracing as the housing market soars further past attainability for the average home buyer and year-round rentals seem to get scarcer all the time.

For many, ADUs and guest houses are a lifeline — the difference between building a life on the Vineyard and being forced to move off-Island. And with a new state law allowing property owners to build ADUs more easily than ever before, Island officials and housing activists are increasingly viewing secondary structures as a key piece of the Vineyard’s housing puzzle.

For Grace, pursuing her dream of helping to feed the Island community would be impossible if it weren’t for the family guest house that she lives in for the majority of the year.

“I can step forward every single day and put 100 per cent into being on the farm, because I can come home to this,” she said.

Grace didn’t grow up on the Island, but her grandparents have lived here for her entire life. Her family briefly lived with them year-round when she was little, but after that, she began spending her summers with them.

During the pandemic and her senior year of high school, Grace moved to the Island and started working for Morning Glory Farm. She started out on the flower farm, where she eventually became manager, then transitioned to the field crew to farm vegetable crops and livestock. After just a year, she was promoted to field manager, and now she holds the job year-round.

“I’m really passionate, and I’m really good at what I do,” she said.

Grace said that having stable, comfortable housing is the reason she can be fully present on the farm each day. And not having to pay average Island rental prices allows her to build up her savings — a rarity on a farmer’s salary.

“I absolutely would not be pursuing a career as a farmer on the Island [otherwise],” she said.

According to Philippe Jordi, CEO of Island Housing Trust (IHT), guest houses and ADUs could be poised to become a more mainstream housing solution as the cost of Island living increases.

“There’s a long history of guest houses [on the Island],” he said. “It goes back generations.”

ADUs and guest houses are often conflated, but there’s technically a difference, Philippe explained. While guest houses are generally only allowed on land parcels of a certain size, ADUs are now allowed on lots of any size in Massachusetts as long as they meet certain setback and health requirements. The law allowing this, known as “ADU by right,” passed in 2024.

Though they’re often kept in families, certain ADUs and guest houses can be rented out year-round, meaning they have the potential to meaningfully increase year-round housing stock for the entire Island.

Philippe is optimistic about ADUs and guest houses as part of a long-term housing solution on the Vineyard. The hope, he said, is that if more property owners decide to build secondary structures on their properties, the Island’s year-round rental stock could meaningfully increase. IHT is working on setting up an ADU resource center to help Islanders create more housing on their properties.

“I think it has shown to be a model that is well-suited for the Island,” Philippe said.

Young, working Islanders, said Grace, often have to contend with grim housing situations. She said her peers commonly live in dwellings without an attached kitchen or bathroom, share their space with a large number of roommates or need to constantly relocate — a phenomenon known colloquially as the “Vineyard shuffle.”

Hearing about her friends’ housing situations reminds her how much she has to be grateful for.

“I have a clean shower, I have space to put all my things. I’m not living with four random people that I just met,” she said. “I have my own kitchen system, and it can be as weird and wonky as I want, because it can be my space.”

Living on her grandparents’ property has also allowed her to grow her relationship with them in a way she never thought possible. Grace sees her grandparents both as mentors and as a cornerstone of her intergenerational social group; often, they’ll walk down to the guest house to join Grace and her friends for pizza and beer.

“They provide me with so much wisdom every single day,” she said.

Straddling the line between independent and family living is not something every young person enthusiastically embraces, specifically in America, where a certain mythology surrounds moving out as a rite of passage for young adults.

“In the majority of America, we have a lot less emphasis on a strong family unit than many other cultures do,” she said.

But to Grace, it’s all just noise.

“It’ll hit me once a year, like, oh, man, I’m still living with my family,” she said. “But I don’t really feel very self-conscious about it at all.”

Grace’s guest house is instantly inviting. It boasts high ceilings, dark wood features and a cozy sitting area with a full view of the backyard. Christmas lights drape from the ceiling’s horizontal beams, and bundles of dried flowers, which Grace harvested at Morning Glory years ago, hang upside down from the kitchen entryway.

“I just want to cram my personality into every single corner of the house,” she said.

Slotted into the house’s nooks and crannies are surfboards. Grace learned to surf with her dad at Squibnocket when she was young, and now it’s a lifestyle. When deep winter freezes the Island, she travels the world catching waves in places such as Costa Rica, Nicaragua, Morocco and, most recently, Indonesia. It’s a life she said is only possible because she saves money by living at home.

“I’m super lucky that I get to do all those things because I get to live on my family’s property,” she said.

Though the décor is thoroughly Grace, it’s also a family affair. Perched on a shelf are two shadowboxes made by her grandmother depicting scenes from inside a home. The rooms are outfitted with miniature wicker chairs and clocks, immaculately detailed.

“When my grandmother was younger, she wanted to be an architect, a builder or a general contractor, but women could not be those things at the time,” she said. “So she handmade all of these tiny little props, because she was allowed to play with dolls.”

The living room’s sliding glass door leads to a spacious back patio flanked by blueberry bushes, raspberry canes and an outdoor shower. With warmer weather approaching, the space is a work in progress.

“This weekend, actually, I’m gonna put posts in at either end [of the patio], and then hang some lights up,” she said. “For the most part, I’ll keep [them] off, but making pizzas after work needs a little bit more light.”

The pizzas in question come from an oven on the backyard’s edge that Grace built from scratch, aided by her friend and the five-year-old girl she babysits. It’s made of hand-poured concrete, and an array of shells and vibrant stone

s are lovingly pressed into its plaster dome. Grace acknowledged it may crumble someday — she noted pizza ovens have a habit of it — but she’ll just make another one.

“Not a single man really helped with that,” she added, gesturing to the charred invention.

The oven is a testament to the property brought to its full glory by women, starting with her grandmother. Grace’s grandmother spearheads renovations, landscaping and repairs and tends a large vegetable garden just a few steps away from the guest house — the reason Grace first discovered her love of farming.

Grace said both her grandmother and mother have long instilled in her that women should be empowered in their independence.

“I have never spent a day in my life thinking that I would need a man in my home with me to make things work,” she said. “That bleeds through in every little bit of the property.”

Now, the property is empowering Grace’s generation. In the summer, her sister and cousin join her in the guest house, and together, the three women make it a home.

“The three of us take care of things here,” Grace said. “It’s a space where we get to experiment and build and be like all the guys on the Island that I looked up to, and use tools and have a good time.”

For Grace, the guest house embodies both independence and kinship with the women in her life. Having a space of her own empowers her to farm to feed the Island and travel the world, and she doesn’t plan to move any time soon — or maybe ever.

Emma Kilbride is a reporter for the Vineyard Gazette.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *