Aquinnah voters at the annual town meeting Tuesday gave the initial approval for funding for town infrastructure improvements and passed an article that begins the process of changing the use of two parcels at the Aquinnah Circle.
Eighty-seven residents attended the meeting and passed every article on the 31-article warrant over the course of the three-hour town meeting.
Some of the big-ticket funding items included $150,000 to repair the town hall parking lot, $300,000 to repair trim and windows at the town hall and firehouse, and $100,000 in additional real estate and property taxes to cover school costs.
All of the items will also need approval at Thursday’s election.

The town’s crumbling buildings and infrastructure were a large priority for town officials.
“We are taking a sort of a stepped approach to the buildings here, and we’re trying to limit the financial burden by doing it that way,” said Adrian Higgins, a member of the town infrastructure committee. “We can fix this in the cheapest way possible. That’s our goal.”
The article that spurred the most discussion was article 17, which proposed authorizing the select board to transfer two parcels of land at Aquinnah Circle North, either by sale or conveyance, to be used for “community-serving, cultural and educational uses.”
The article also asked that the select board start a request for proposals process for the disposition of the properties, which are home to the Gay Head Lighthouse and the nearby restaurant.
NaDaizja Bolling, the executive director at the Aquinnah Cultural Center, moved to have the article amended so the select board could lead an effort to reclaim the space for recreational use.
The amendment allows 60 days for the select board to establish a process to dispose of or enter a long term lease agreement for the two parcels located at Circle North.
According to Derrill Bazzy, a member of the community preservation committee who spoke in favor of the amendment, the lots are totally unbuildable for either residential or commercial use.

Some town members present at the town meeting spoke out against the amendment, worrying that the value of the land was being overlooked.
While there was an initial request to table the article until a later date, the amendment passed 65-17 and the article passed 50-24.
Many voters expressed their support, stating that the area, which was previously owned by Helen Manning, should be reserved as a historical and cultural site to maintain the beauty and draw of the Island.
“When the town purchased it in 2004, the idea was to put in a park to honor Helen,” said resident Berta Welch. “[The buildings] are an eyesore for that whole area and for our town. We need to make a decision and we have young people who have great ideas and have the energy to move this forward.”
There was some confusion among members of the community who believed the article hadn't met the two-thirds majority threshold to pass since there were 76 voters at the meeting at the time of the vote. However, two abstentions weren't counted towards the total tally, allowing the article to just squeak by.
Article 14, which establishes Aquinnah as a Fourth Amendment Workplace Community, was approved. This effectively reinforces the town’s ability to support efforts to inform town staff and residents on their Fourth Amendment rights, which protects U.S. citizens from illegal search and seizure.
“This is a resolution that commits our town to constitutional protection against unreasonable search and seizure and assurances of the right to privacy,” said Ruth Folchman.

Residents voted to increase the area and scope of the town’s ground lease at the Carl Widdiss Way housing project near town hall. This allows the town to explore a second phase of the housing project, potentially adding four more units to the proposed area.
Town members also voted in favor of transferring an available $46,300 in funds to purchase a rapid food waste recycler.
“Climate change is already affecting our world right now, and it won’t stop growing as an issue until we take initiative and do something about it right now,” said Emmett Taylor, a junior at Martha’s Vineyard High School whose been working on a project at school that’s focused on the food waste recyclers on the Island. “Voting for the food waste recycler tonight is the next step forward for us.”
Chilmark, West Tisbury and Edgartown have all approved similar efforts this town meeting season.
Town meeting also featured several honors to residents and Island workers. A moment of silence was held for residents who had died in the last year, and applause was given to staff who had retired, including department of public works director Jay Smalley, harbor master and shellfish warden Chip Vanderhoop and finance committee chairman Alan Rugg.
Police Chief Randhi Belain recognized Paul Manning, for his 24 years of service in the Aquinnah Police Department.
“Thank you for your professionalism, your courteous nature to everybody in this town, to the public, and for being here when I could thank you,” said Chief Belain.
Editor's note: this article has been updated with more information about the Circle North vote.
This article appears in May 15, 2026.
