
Susan Bainbridge Murphy died peacefully and painlessly from cancer at the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital on August 6. She was surrounded by her family and dearest friends.
Susan was born in Buffalo, N.Y., the oldest of four children to Richard and Margaret (Peggy) Bainbridge, née Sheehan. She attended Nardin Academy in Buffalo and graduated from Vassar College with a degree in art history. She later attended the cabinet and fine furniture program at the North Bennett Street School in Boston.
She was a wife, mother, stepmother, grandmother, sister, aunt, friend and consummate Chilmark board member. Her devotion to her family, friends, work and hobbies was remarkable. As a loving wife to Lynn, she worked side-by-side — in all weather and circumstances — in the Menemsha Marine Repair business, setting moorings and moving and maintaining large and small watercraft.
As a devoted mother to her sons Lynn and Lucas, she encouraged a love of learning and the adventure of travel. She deeply loved her sisters, brother, nieces and nephews. She was profoundly saddened by the death of sister Barbara in 2022.
Her friendships were many, varied, valued and long-lasting, including childhood friends, college friends and a close group of island girlfriends. Everyone with a Chilmark postal mailbox could count on her incredible memory to recall their box numbers and remember their significant life events in the precise year they occurred. Who among us has not received a handwritten card or note from her?
An Anglophile and avid art lover, she lived in London after college and knew every art museum in the city, its collection, its address and what tube line could get her there. An admirer of William Henry Morris, she covered the walls of her Chilmark home with hand-printed wallpaper depicting the designs of Morris’ art. A talented gardener and blueberry farmer, she was inspired by her many visits to the glorious gardens at Vita Sackville-West’s Sissinghurst in Cranbrook, United Kingdom, even before her time as education coordinator at Polly Hill Arboretum.
During the production of the movie Jaws, She worked tirelessly beside her husband Lynn, who was credited with figuring out how to make the recalcitrant, mechanical shark travel underwater and perform realistically. Actors, directors, set designers and special effects coordinators became part of the Murphy/Jaws family. Jaws fans from all over the world stayed in touch with her and will be saddened at the loss of their Jaws connection.
The town of Chilmark is the beneficiary of Susan’s articulate and intelligent participation in town government. She has served as postmaster, on the school committee, building committees, Friends of the Chilmark Library, finance committee and Harbor advisory committee. She also served as the Superintendent of the Abel’s Hill Cemetery, where she will be laid to rest beside husband Lynn and son Lynn II.
She was a profoundly talented seamstress, knitter and a life-long learner. She recently built herself a left-handed banjo and began taking music lessons.
She leaves behind her son, Lucas, daughter-in-law, Tricia and grandson, Tracy of Easton, Mass. and Chilmark; stepchildren Wanda (Bert) Irion of Wellsboro, Pa.; Sherry (Carl) Flanders of Chilmark, Brian (Joanne) Murphy of Vineyard Haven; Dana Murphy of Florida; sister Elizabeth Bainbridge Schmelzinger of Manassas, Va.; brother Rick Bainbridge of Charlotte, N.C. and many much-loved nieces and nephews.
She was predeceased by her parents; her husband Lynn Murphy; son, Lynn II; sister Barbara; and nephew Michael Schmelzinger.
Interment will be at Abel’s Hill Cemetery.
A celebration of Susan’s life will be held at 2 p.m. on Oct. 19 at the Chilmark Community Center. Donations can be made in Susan’s name to the Friends of the Chilmark Library, P.O. Box 434, Chilmark, MA 02535.

Susan was passionate about so much
We loved her for that
Ever in our hearts
In 1973 a young Susan Bainbridge applied to teach swimming at the Chilmark Community Center. She had a degree from Vassar and a certificate as a Red Cross Water Safety Instructor and, of course, I hired her. And she came. And she decided to stay on for the winter, which turned out to be for the rest of her life. She was all those things described in her obituary and a friend. We’ll all miss her.
Susan NEVER had a dull moment in her life…there is a book to be written-hell a movie too…wife -mother-housekeeper-Postmistress and longtime caretaker of Lynn when Alsiemers took his mind away.God bless you say hello to all our friends….
Susan was an adventurous soul. We are so sorry you are going through this . Your Mom was very special and you and your family spent so much time with her. The most important thing is LOVE and she knew she was loved.
Susan was a kind and welcoming mother to Lucas and all of his friends. My wife and I loved visiting Lucas and his family on Martha’s Vineyard. We loved seeing her amazing woodworking and artwork accompanying Lynn’s mechanical wonders. Such a beautiful pair.
My wife and I miss her and Lynn and her beautiful family and home. She was a very special person and very kind to all.
Susan was an amazing woman with a very big heart, with room for everyone she knew. I was in awe of her beauty, kindness, compassion, intelligence and brave spirit. I am so very grateful to Susan for raising such an awesome family man as Lucas for my daughter Trish and grandson Tracy. Thank you Susan for being my friend. I know you are with your beloved husband and son.
This beautifully captures the Susan we knew so well and loved so much. She has been a robust and valuable presence in Chilmark and island life for many years, and yet too few. We miss you, Susan.
Susan was the cousin I connected with later in life. We found we had the same taste in music, sewing, and museums. We both loved travel, antiques and. So much more. We had so much fun together. We spoke on the phone frequently and would laugh until we cried.
How I will miss her!
After reading Matt Taylor’s book on the making of Jaws, I was fascinated by Lynn & Susan’s contributions behind the scenes, to help make that movie a masterpiece. The summer of my first trip to MV, I was delighted to find out, by pure coincidence, that we were staying next to the Murphys. The good captain had passed on in the previous winter, and I did not want to be a pestering fanboy, so I stayed on our rented property. Just knowing I was neighbors to folks such as them, gave me peace I will never forget I named our new puppy Murphy in honor Lynn & Susan Fair seas, and following winds
Sue and I met at Vassar College where we both studied and lived in a cooperative dorm, Ferry House. Sue, Doria Rosen and I, along with Geoff Feldman and two other Vassar coeds spent spring break of 1972 at Geoff’s then-family house in Chilmark. That was Sue’s first visit to the Vineyard. She fell for the place and the people, and as you know, lived there for the rest of her life minus her year in London.
We connected again after I returned from Brazil and we met up when I worked on the Vineyard from time to time, She hosted me a few times. The very last time was just before the pandemic hit when she invited Doria and me to her place and guided us around the 150th Illumination Night. She was hospitable, kind, generous, talented, hardworking and more. There is not enough space here to say everything I would like to about Sue. Now I know why she never returned my last phone call. I am so devastated for her family and tremendously sad to think she won’t be up on Rumpus Lane and there will be no more deep and loving conversations.
Susan and I were classmates at Vassar though. I didn’t meet her until one of our class reunions. When I was on the Vineyard, she’d host my aunt, mother and I. We three really enjoyed our visits with she and Lynn. And her blueberries were the best! After my aunt, uncle and mom passed, I didn’t get back to the Vineyard, but I did see Susan at our last class reunion and thought that we’d get to spend time this fall. She was a Master furniture maker and my mom, aunt, and I being artists, really appreciated her work. She was a very kind, selfless, giving person and I will miss her.
Susan was such an energetic and intellectually curious person; always juggling many new projects. I can hear her saying, “you have to come by the house and see what I’m working on!” She will be missed by our family. Words fail…
In 1998 my husband, Steve, and I moved to the island when he became the first Director of the Polly Hill Arboretum. Susan was among the very first people to volunteer to help with initial activities at the PHA. She was a ball of energy and all smiles and fun! She made a full size Tree costume with removable and replaceable parts. She wore it with pride and excitement. I will sorely miss her. The Vineyard has lost a treasure. Her Obituary is simply spot on perfect!
We were was so sorry to hear the sad news . Susan was a lovely person, so talented and excelled in everything she did.We have such happy memories of our friendship with her and Lynn forged through the West Tisbury school exchange programme. Our thoughts are with her friends and family .
Sue and I shared art classes at Vassar & the Ferry co-op house. She was one of my dearest college friends. After our 50th reunion, she drove to see her sister. Soon after, she came to my home and we attended a Blue Grass Festival nearby. I learned then that Sue knew about that whole world of music. I had not known her interest was so deep. She was passionate about so much of life, despite the tragedies she suffered. Sue was a woman who will always remain in my heart.
She gave me my first job. RIP Susan.
Buffalo based friends of Susan from grammar school in Orchard park and St.Marks, Nardin high school and freshman year at Fordham University met last night. We held a moment to remember our old and loyal friend from our youth and to toast the memory of all that Susan accomplished in a remarkably varied and full life. She will be missed by us all.
I met Susan through the Edward and Susan Hughes family the summer after our sophomore year at Vassar. We hadn’t crossed paths at college, but we became friends afterwards. I was lucky enough to spend several vacations on the Vineyard, hosted by Susan and Lynn, the first being when Lynn II was only a few weeks old. Our lives crossed paths again when Lucas attended Northeastern University at the same time my nephew was there. Turned out that Luke was sharing an apartment with my future niece-in-law!
What a life well lived. I will miss you dear friend.