The Martha’s Vineyard Commission spent another three hours Thursday deliberating on the Katama Meadows subdivision proposal, before continuing the public hearing to August 6.
First, however, the commission voted to make the contentious mixed-income development a smaller project, approving a condition that would replace seven of the 26 market-rate home sites with open space, leaving 19 market-rate lots and 26 with income restrictions.
“We do have the authority to do this,” said commissioner Douglas Sederholm, who proposed the condition.
The change would reduce the project’s nitrogen output significantly by eliminating 35 bedrooms, while increasing the proportion of open space from 50 per cent to 60 per cent of the 54-acre development, he said.
The developers’ proposal had flanked the seven lots in question with two open areas, one of 4.4 acres and one of 21.5 acres, which Mr. Sederholm said were insufficient.
“They’re barely connected and it doesn’t work,” he said.
The condition, which also requires equal access to the open space for all subdivision residents, passed 10-4.
“This makes it a better project,” said commissioner Linda Sibley.
The condition also would spare the developers the cost of constructing a road to serve the seven lots, commissioners said.
Mark Gauthier, Daniel McGinn, Brian Smith and chair Peter Wharton voted no, with Mr. Smith saying he would support replacing five homesites with open space, but not seven.
Commissioners also voted to prohibit the use of fertilizers, pesticides and herbicides on all lawns in the subdivision, allowing slow-release fertilizers only for gardens.
The commision must still vote on whether to approve the project overall with conditions, or deny it. The conditions voted on Thursday would only go into effect if the project is ultimately approved.
When the public hearing resumes August 6, commissioners will continue discussing conditions regarding solar power generation for the Katama Meadows homes.
This article appears in August 7, 2026.

This is a great project that’s been through so many iterations and whittle down the next to nothing. It’s time to approve it and move on.
No. Deny the whole project. No more houses and traffic om MV
agree
Prohibiting fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides sounds good on paper but all it will ever be is on paper.
this is right next to the affordable housing thing? a little overcrowded there …. it appears that there is not enough parking there. cars and trailers not in parking spots…
The affordable housing “thing”? Really?
There is no way to enforce the prohibition to applying chemicals to lawns. I am an abutter to a project MVC approved with the same condition and have watched the lack of enforcement of this and other conditions for 20 years. These conditions may make commissioners feel better about approving a project but can not and are not enforced.
If this project cannot be connected to Edgartowns waste water system it should be denied, period.
Just like the Navigator x MVH asphalt paradise?
Development is not our friend. It hasn’t worked in the past and it will not work now. Ancient woodlands, or maybe food forests are needed not more houses, trash, lights, noise, tick spraying and traffic. The ADUs were supposed to help locals but its already being taken over. Deny Katama Meadows
So all the rich folks got to build their McMansions but we wee people have to continue our couch surfing to live on this island? How generous of you.
This is a great project that needs to be approved. Hopefully, I don’t cut anymore out of it so I can stay viable in this can get done
the loudest voices of opposition are those nearby who already have their peices of paradise jammed into 1/2 acre lots
Actually the loudest opposing voices are the conservationists and even some housing advocates like me who see this for what it is – a subdivision money-maker for the developer with no obligation to build.
The Island simply cannot afford any more growth. How is that not obvious?
Our ponds are already suffering from nitrogen pollution, summer traffic can turn a short drive into a 30-minute ordeal, and our infrastructure is stretched beyond its intended capacity. Every new development, regardless of how well intended, adds more vehicles, wastewater, demand for services, and pressure on the environment. Martha’s Vineyard has a finite carrying capacity, and we’ve already exceeded it. At some point, we have to acknowledge that reality instead of continuing to approve projects that only make these problems worse.
Deny this project, bad for the island , bad for the pond, bad for the developments that are already surrounding this important open space , over development on the ISLAND.
BUILD,BUILD,BUILD