The former Oak Bluffs fire chief was given 14 months of probation this week connected to allegations that he had set up a hidden camera in a teenage girl’s bedroom.
John Rose, 54, entered a plea in Edgartown District Court on Monday, admitting to sufficient facts for a finding of guilty for two counts of attempt to commit a crime.
An investigation into Mr. Rose began in December of 2023, after the 14-year-old daughter of a woman Mr. Rose was dating found a device in her room, assistant district attorney Aileen Kirwin said during Monday’s hearing.
When the girl brought the device to the attention of her mother and Mr. Rose, Mr. Rose allegedly said he didn’t know what it was. The girl later approached the mother and said that she believed it was a hidden camera, and the mother brought her daughter to her ex-husband’s house to get her out of their home in Oak Bluffs.
Ms. Kirwin described the device as a USB charging device with a small hole that housed a lens, and said that the camera was in the 14-year-old’s room near her mirror where she changed her clothes.
The mother turned the device over to police, according to Ms. Kirwin. Mr. Rose tried to delay her from handing it over at one point, saying he had to call his lawyer beforehand, the assistant district attorney told the court.
Police went on to execute a search warrant for Mr. Rose’s home and devices. Investigators said it appeared that Mr. Rose had cleaned out his property and left in a hurry when he learned that police were starting to look into the device.
When police searched Mr. Rose’s devices, they found that much of the files had been deleted, Ms. Kirwin said. Some of those trashed items were recovered, but they found little aside from searches about how to permanently delete items from a device, she told the court.
Monday’s hearing was the fullest recounting of the details behind the allegations against Mr. Rose. Police reports on the case were not available due to the incident involving a minor, a court clerk told the Gazette.
Mr. Rose previously pleaded not guilty to the charges, which included attempting to photograph or videotape a nude or partially nude person, and attempting to pose or exhibit a child in a state of nudity or sexual conduct.
Mr. Rose’s attorney said that his client has been seeking treatment, even before he was arrested. Mr. Rose had traveled to Florida to go to an inpatient facility that specializes in mental health, trauma and substance abuse to receive treatment, said lawyer Elliot Weinstein.
“Colloquially, he looked in the mirror and said, ‘I have to do something,’” Mr. Weinstein said.
Mr. Rose spent 30 days there and was arrested at Logan Airport when he returned to Massachusetts.
The hidden camera case was the second round of charges that prosecutors brought against Mr. Rose. Initially, they charged him with “photographing, videotaping, or electronically surveilling a partially nude or nude persons” for filming a woman having sex with him without her consent.
That charge was dismissed by the court Monday, partially due to the plea agreement and partially due to issues with evidence in the case, according to the Cape and Islands District Attorney’s Office.
A victim-impact statement from the teenager was filed with the court on Monday. These statements are often read aloud and can be a factor in sentencing. On Monday, the teenager’s statement was read privately by district court Judge Benjamin Barnes.
There was a disagreement on the length of probation for Mr. Rose. His attorney had recommended that the former fire chief receive one year of probation.
“I’m asking for one year because, for practical purposes, since his arrest in January 2024, Mr. Rose has been on supervised pretrial probation without any specific offending events, other than one issue of a contact in a public area,” Mr. Weinstein said.
The district attorney’s office argued for 18 months.
Judge Barnes ordered 14 months of probation, and said that Mr. Rose needs to continue his therapy sessions during that time period, and stay away from the victims.
Mr. Rose attended Monday’s hearing along with a family member, and he and his lawyer declined to comment after the hearing. By admitting to sufficient facts, Mr. Rose waived his right to a jury trial, and must have no further offenses for the probationary period.
Mr. Rose had served as the Oak Bluffs fire chief for seven years before stepping down in 2020. He later took a job as a firefighter in West Tisbury but was put on indefinite suspension during the investigation into the filming cases.
In 2019, the town of Oak Bluffs settled a sexual harassment and discrimination lawsuit against Mr. Rose. The town ended up paying nearly $100,000 to a former fire department administrator who claimed she was harassed by Mr. Rose.
The department was also investigated by the FBI for its ambulance billing practices while Mr. Rose was chief.
This article appears in March 27, 2026.

Only probation? This guy completely violated this young girl’s privacy and he gets a slap on the wrist. He should be under the jail. If the girl were less aware who knows what would have happened.
PROBATION?? Seems like a very light sentence. Can someone explain this to me?
This is pedophile protection. That 14 yr. old is a child, make no mistake. I’m ashamed for this court and outraged for her. He should have been sentenced to jail.
Are you kidding me? Probation and he keeps his pension? No wonder our Country is in the state that we are.
This is exactly why victims don’t pursue “justice.” Thinking about all that victim went through to realize what happened, tell her parents, authorities and work through what happened to her: a man who has a documented history of violating and exploiting others is basically told to not do it again, for one year, and all is well. I understand that he is a deeply troubled man, but he took advantage of his authority and has a pattern of this behavior. I don’t get it.
What a disgusting person. He should be in jail.
How a person who admits to photographing a teenaged girl in her bedroom with a hidden camera in the mirror she uses to look at herself while changing does not get sentenced to jail is baffling
Especially with his history. What are our Judges thinking?
I keep coming back to the same question: would this outcome be the same if this weren’t a former fire chief?
Because what’s described here isn’t complicated.
A hidden camera disguised as a charger, placed in a 14-year-old girl’s bedroom. Positioned near a mirror where she changed clothes. Then deleted files, searches on how to permanently erase evidence, and an attempt to delay turning the device over.
That’s not a gray area.
That’s intent.
And it ends in 14 months of probation.
We’re told he sought treatment. Fine. That may matter for him. But treatment is not accountability, and it doesn’t undo what was done to that girl in her own room — a place that’s supposed to feel safe.
And it raises another uncomfortable question: how many years had this been going on before he was caught? Much of the evidence was deleted. That uncertainty alone should give people pause.
So yes, people are going to ask whether status mattered here. Because when something this deliberate, this invasive, involving a minor, results in probation, it doesn’t read like justice.
It reads like something negotiated down.
And when lines like this start to blur, public trust goes with them.
Convenient for him. Disgusting for everyone else.
Sadly, I do think this is more complicated than you outline. I’m not an attorney but he admitted to sufficient facts that would be likely to lead to a guilty verdict. Unfortunately, he wiped away a lot of the evidence so I’m guessing the prosecution thought they had a tougher case than if they got a hold of his deleted files. Admitting to sufficient facts is far different than admitting guilt. Now if the prosecution was confident they could have convicted him and decided to settle in this fashion, I agree with you and every other commenter..it’s disgraceful. And the fact he doesn’t have to register as a sex offender if awful. He is highly likely to reoffend.
I understand the point you’re making, and I don’t disagree that evidence issues and legal thresholds can shape how a case is resolved.
But simply invoking that doesn’t really change what people are reacting to here.
Because the facts laid out are not subtle. A hidden camera disguised as a charger, placed in a 14-year-old’s bedroom, positioned where she changed. Deleted files. Searches on how to permanently erase evidence. That’s not a borderline case in the way people understand it.
If anything, the possibility that evidence was destroyed or couldn’t be fully recovered only deepens the concern. It doesn’t lessen the seriousness — it highlights a gap between what may have occurred and what could ultimately be proven.
And that’s exactly where the disconnect comes in.
People aren’t parsing legal strategy or burden-of-proof standards. They’re looking at what’s described and then looking at the outcome. When those two don’t line up, it raises real questions about accountability, deterrence, and whether the system is meeting the moment in cases like this.
So yes, it may be more complicated from a legal standpoint.
But complication doesn’t resolve the core issue — it underscores it.
Legally complicated or not, this doesn’t read like justice.
Is he required to register as a sex offender ?
You’d think in this age of Epstein that our justice system would focus more intently on protecting our teenage girls and punish more meaningfully those who behave this way…to deter others who might act similarly in the future. This is a slap on the hand for a disgusting creep in our midst. Justice not served.
Infuriating and a terrible lesson all around. A 14 year old showed infinitely more courage and common sense than the adults running the justice system that’s supposed to protect her (and others) from predators like John Rose.
I do feel compassion for Mr. Rose and hope he gets the treatment that he needs. However, I also feel these to be major charges against a minor and warrant harsher punishment. He’s likely to reoffend just as he’s committed previous sexual improprieties and should be banned from our island. Acts against children are unforgivable.
I feel like we are forgetting he was filming a child
Wow! This guy has a sordid past and has changed the life of a child forever. Thank god she’s a smart girl. No jail time? No ankle monitor? No justice here!
I am utterly horrified by the message this sends to this brave, strong young woman, as well as all of her peers. They have all witnessed her go through a long, incredibly challenging process, and it ended with barely even a slap on the wrist for this man?? This is so disturbing, and would not surprise me at all if it results in one less teenager, or future adult, who questions whether they should report something knowing all that she went through resulted this way. I am proud that she was so brave in reporting, and so disgusted by how greatly the judicial system failed her.