Voters by now have received their little red pamphlets that explain the ballot questions for the up-coming election. There is a lot more to this election than who will be our governor and representatives in Washington, Boston and the county courthouse.
Read question 7; it is one that might rattle some of us. It is an extreme solution to the affordable housing problem. It would allow construction of a single family home on a lot as small as 5,000 square feet, if it has 50 feet of frontage on any kind of road, and public access to water and sewage. Some 2,613 houses (very theoretically) could be built inside a three-acre lot, the size now required for a house lot in our town.
West Tisbury and up-Island would not be directly affected by such a law because we don’t have public sewers or water, but it could certainly be applied in Edgartown and parts of Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs.
Consider the traffic on our roads, the size of the high school, the hospital, the ferry service, dentists, eye doctors, even post office boxes and the depth of services of all kinds. Forget about local zoning and planning, or the charms of existing neighborhoods, public safety and policing, or environmental conditions.
This outcome of the question is worrisome because it goes to every voter in the state, not just in our region. If it passes in places like Dartmouth, Brimfield, Goshen and Cambridge, for example, we are threatened. These voters are not going to consider the sensitive feelings of people who live on Martha’s Vineyard.
Developers may well pile in here with plans for massive enclaves that could disorder life on the Island. It is a lot harder to battle our enemies when the law is on their side.
Is it morally wrong to resist development on such a scale? A number of creative thinkers have offered ideas to resolve the affordable housing problems. And ADUs (accessory dwelling units) are already making a dent across the state.
I am truly sympathetic with those who have Island roots or connections, and who want to live here. But do we need to accommodate others who want to move here because the place is popular and desirable right now? Yes we do. Sigh.
Anna Alley has guests arriving this weekend. They are Anna’s years-ago Boston roommate Denise Mount, who now lives in Connecticut. And Vicki Galler from Boston, both coming for a few days.
The celebration to honor Trip Barnes that was planned for this Sunday has been moved to Nov. 21 due to the weather.
Happy birthday to Roan Bettencourt on Saturday, Sept. 26. It is celebration day for Lynn Christoffers and Megan Mendenhall, Wednesday, Sept. 29, and Sept. 30 will be the big day for Roan’s mother, Becky Cournoyer, and well as artist Traeger DiPietro. Missy Manter celebrates her birthday on Thursday, Oct. 1.
Congratulations and happy wedding anniversary to Chief Dan and Jane Rossi on Monday, Sept. 28.
This article appears in September 25 2026.
