mp_pollinators_igi_090723_2
A pollinator pathway at Island Grown Initiative. - Matt Pelikan

When it comes to pollinators in Morning Glory’s fields, farm production manager Ryan Hassell would have guessed a few years ago that only 15 species of bees and butterflies turn up at the farm.

He would have been wrong: by nearly one hundred.

Island-wide, that number is even higher. At least 283 distinct species of pollinators and 66 species of bees visit farms across the Vineyard, according to a report from Pollinator Pathways, a study from BiodiversityWorks funded by the Betsy and Jesse Fink Family Foundation, seasonal Islanders who focus the foundation’s efforts on environmental causes.

The study installed small plots of native plants on eight farms in 2022, including Morning Glory Farm. For the next three years, observers identified species and noted how many pollinators visited the installed strips of goldenrod, asters, butterfly weed and scarlet beebalm, along with existing areas of the farm around the test plots.

With almost 1,000 acres of land under cultivation on the Island, farming is a high leverage industry to address habitat fragmentation, one of the biggest problems facing specialized pollinators today. Unlike the less-discriminating honeybees, specialized pollinators such as native bees visit a limited number of plant species, making them more at risk for endangerment.

“We began with a simple question: if farms occupy a large portion of the Island’s open land, could they also become some of its most important habitat?” wrote Betsy Fink of the Fink Family Foundation, in a statement to the Gazette.

The answer, according to the study, is yes — and they likely already are. While the goldenrods, sunflowers and asters in test plots certainly attracted pollinators, other farm areas proved to be important existing habitat, from crops like squash and fennel to field edges of cone flowers and Queen Anne’s lace.

At Island Grown Initiative (IGI), test species were planted right next to the community garden, providing food sources to an area where colorful zinnias, bolting kale and flowering clover already attracted pollinators.

Morning Glory and Whippoorwill Farm are both located close to preservation areas, also important habitats for specialized pollinators, according to Matt Pelikan, community naturalist at BiodiversityWorks and the primary author of the report. Pollinators don’t travel very far to forage for food, so it matters what farms have close by — state forests down the road or weeds down the row.

“If all the farms on the Island put in a patch of goldenrods, or more than one patch on some of the larger farms, that would sort of stitch the landscape together for these specialized bees,” said Mr. Pelikan. “It would turn the Island into a much more connected area of resources.”

One of the project’s recommendations for attracting pollinators was to maintain “physical messiness” on unmanaged areas and field edges of farms, said Mr. Pelikan. “It’s hard to find a sort of a polite way to put this,” said Mr. Pelikan. “But between the tidy farms and the untidy farms, the less groomed and the crappier looking a farm is, the better it is for insects.”

Less grooming also means more structural complexity. Unweeded areas provide habitat for insects to shelter, breed and lay eggs, boosting biodiversity and pollination on farms.

Caitlin Jones, owner of Mermaid Farm and Dairy and a participant in the study, said she has often felt protective of the unmanaged areas around her farm, scolding her sons and husband when they mow down the “walls” of milkweed and goldenrod.

Those walls of goldenrod, according to the study, were part of what made her test plot so successful: pollinators were already hanging out at the plants around her farm.

Still, there’s a tradeoff when considering the aesthetics of a property, especially those that see numerous visitors in the summer.

“People have problems with the way my farm looks, and I do too,” said Ms. Jones. “You kind of have to leave everything a mess.”

Unmanaged areas can pose another problem: undesirable insects like aphids and beetles, said Mr. Hassell.

“It’s tough because it’s habitat for the beneficial insects, and also the predatory bugs that can come in and ruin a crop,” he said.

Assigning value to biodiversity — thinking of pollinators as another crop on a farm — can help with those decisions.

“Growing pollinators is sort of an investment,” said Molly Jacobson, a pollinator ecologist at SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry who worked on the study. While they don’t have a specific monetary value, pollinators provide ecosystem services to farms, pollinating crops and attacking predatory insects.

Ms. Jones can attest to that. Hornets on her property attack cabbage loopers on her brassicas, she said. They also swoop down to grab the flies that hang around the cows, a relief at the dairy in the hot, fly-ridden summer.

Ms. Fink’s own experience with farming was a positive one with pollinators. When operating a 72-acre farm in Connecticut in 2005, she and her husband Jesse Fink saw the mutually beneficial impact of farms and pollinators when experimenting with fields, hedgerows and pollinator strips.

“We saw firsthand that when biodiversity increased, so did the productivity of the crops,” Ms. Fink wrote. “Supporting insects wasn’t separate from farming, it improved farming.”

Farms aren’t the only ones that can support pollinators, however. Small scale changes, even at the individual or residential level, can have large scale results.

“Hopefully this can provide some impetus for nurseries to carry plants that are more specific to these conditions, and get people planting things,” said Ms. Jones.

Mr. Pelikan recalled converting his own front yard of hydrangeas and hydroseeded grass into meadow, and watching all kinds of specialist bees turn up. It’s called “microhabitat modification,” and anybody with a small plot of soil, from homeowners to businesses to farms big and small, can do it.

“Stick some goldenrod in, and you’d be surprised what turns up on it,” said Mr. Pelikan.

What might turn up are any of the almost 300 species of insects identified during the study. What also might turn up are two species of bees previously unidentified on the Island.

One of those bees is Megachile Inimica, a bee mostly found in Central America and the southern United States. Its identification in the northeast could provide evidence for northward migrations caused by climate change, implicating the Island’s unique ecological position. Because Martha’s Vineyard has a more temperate climate than much of the northeast, the Island could represent an “outpost” or “first stop” for displaced species, said Mary Sage Napolitan, regenerative landscape manager at IGI.

Ms. Jacobson said it’s more a matter of the Vineyard’s distinct ecology of acidic, sandy soils that support unique plants and therefore unique polinators. Plant commmunities may have also been better preserved on the Island than in other parts of New England, she added.

“In many cases, for many insects and other wildlife, there has been sort of a refuge or a holdout on the Island where that habit has been lost on the mainland,” said Ms. Jacobson. “There are surviving populations of things on the Vineyard that might have already been lost from elsewhere.”

When the study ended, IGI kept the native plants in their plot and added more, said Ms. Napolitan. The mixed-native flowers at the border of the community garden continues to support pollinators on the property, even if they’re no longer being counted.

“We are seeing massive pollinator activity on our own farm,” said Ms. Napolitan. “Whatever it is that’s working, it’s working, and that’s great news.”

Join the Conversation

6 Comments

  1. Great work BiodiversityWorks! Your study results are so hopeful, and practical. Here’s hoping our many plant nurseries will follow through by making more of these plants available for our yards, and that we can increase available stock for our hard-working farmers.

  2. Really interesting article and effort! I really learned a lot from this-pollinators, something I always took for granted. Thank you, Fink Family Foundation!

  3. And we can all do this in our own yards. The article is so well written, (though the land around where I live is already a meadow), it has given me some ideas about how to make it more inviting.

  4. Golden rod gets a bad wrap from the general public. It does not cause allergies and is beautiful to look at Plant more golden rod. It is ragweed that’s the culprit for us allergy suffers.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *