Like an overture sounding a few bars of each major theme before the opera begins, representatives of Island towns and the hospital touched on their basic concerns at the first meeting on Monday night of a new task force.

The financial problems of the hospital and especially Windemere, its long-term care facility, were also the prime topics the following day at a joint hospital-Windemere board meeting in the same room, the medical library of the hospital.

Formed at the suggestion of the Dukes County Selectmen’s Association, the task force is to consider whether there should be a mechanism in place so that if needed the towns could directly provide financial support to Martha’s Vineyard Hospital. The original proposal was that the six towns combine to authorize $500,000 for the hospital through town meeting articles.

The organizational meeting without dissent or controversy elected John Early of West Tisbury as chairman, organized tours of the hospital for the task force members, and scheduled its next two meetings, both of which will focus on educating the town representatives about hospital finance and organization.

In accepting the post, Mr. Early said the task force has one specific goal: deciding if the towns should contribute to the hospital, and how such aid should be triggered.

Oak Bluffs selectman Roger Wey promptly noted, however, that his town’s board of selectmen had written the hospital asking for copies of consultant reports and that a complete list of salaries also had been requested.

“We need a hospital, okay?” Mr. Wey said. “We just have to know the full scope of what’s going on. Can Windemere survive? We have to know the answers.”

Cal Howard, chairman of the hospital foundation, said: “You need a broad education. This is a $20 million business.” Salaries are just one piece of information that “is not really going to help you.” He pledged to eventually supply the information, however, as did hospital chief executive officer Abbie Taylor.

“We want to give it to you,” Mrs. Taylor said, “but we want you to understand the whole complexity of it.”

Arthur Smadbeck, an Edgartown selectman, asked the hospital to “tell us the ideal of what you want, and I can go back to my town with the ideal and we can respond.”

After the Island’s reaction to the initial suggestion of a contribution by the towns Ñ “We do a lousy job of p.r. and we’re going to change that,” vowed Mr. Howard Ñ the money figure is “almost off the table,” Mrs. Taylor said. The more important task is to educate the public about the hospital’s situation. But, she said that if, for example, “Medicare gets cut and we’re out $500,000,” rather than close the hospital its management would like to be able to turn to the towns for help.

Task force member Fred Rundlet of Tisbury, himself a hospital administrator in Colorado for more than 20 years, sympathized with the hospital’s plight, noting: “We’re the sole provider. We’re supposed to be everything for everybody.”

Herbert Hancock of Chilmark chimed in, “We may be trying to do too much. We’d be better off letting some things go elsewhere.”

Wayne Bennett, chief financial officer of the hospital, said that Windemere essentially has only to fill another 10 beds to break even, filling 102 of 106 beds instead of the current 92, a number that actually has ticked up to 95 recently. The same subject was explained in greater detail at the board meeting the following day. He also said that adding the new surgeon at the hospital Ñ Dr. Richard Koehler, whose wife, Dr. Kathleen Koehler, also does some surgery here Ñ has helped increase revenues, as many Islanders who might have gone off-Island for surgery have stayed here. And Mrs. Taylor said that bringing in an ophthalmologist, Dr. Frank Sutula, has been helpful, as some 100 Vineyarders have been having cataract operations in Falmouth each year.

Cynthia Mitchell, a West Tisbury selectman who attended the task force meeting in her capacity as chairman of the hospital board, noted that the use of the operating room has increased from 30 per cent to 60 per cent “and he hasn’t been here six months.” Mrs. Taylor added that the hospital’s investment of some $75,000 in laparoscopic surgical equipment has already paid off. “He’s going to make his money back and 10 times over,” she said.

Mr. Hancock warned that the hospital will “have to fight history” in building confidence, and the hospital officials agreed about “past problems,” as Mrs. Taylor called them. Mr. Howard added that now a relatively few people donate some $700,000 a year to the hospital, and it would be better if a broad public base could contribute the extra $500,000 that the towns initially were asked for.

The task force agreed to continue meeting on Monday evenings at 7:30, although town meeting season currently restricts the availability of the selectmen. Tours of the hospital are being conducted for task force members, and on April 24 the meeting will feature the same kind of financial presentation about the hospital that is made to new board members and corporators. On May 8, Robert McGowan of the management consulting firm frequently used by the hospital, McGowan, Phelan and Constello, will give a presentation. Walter Delaney of Gay Head made a point of requesting a copy of the management study done by the firm in advance of the meeting, and the hospital officials agreed to supply all task force members with the material.

At the joint hospital-Windemere board meeting the emphasis was on a marketing plan for Windemere that is designed to reach more potential clients and help fill its beds. Mr. Bennett reported that Windemere in February lost $186,000, although it had been budgeted to lose $50,000, and for the five months of its fiscal year so far has lost $980,000, although it was budgeted to lose $400,000. The hospital in February lost $98,000, although budgeted to lose $145,000, and for the fiscal year so far has lost $250,000, although it had been anticipated to lose $450,000.

Mr. Bennett noted that the winter always sees heavy losses. He also pointed out that he has been allocating as many of the hospital’s expenses as he can to Windemere because the government will repay more of the Windemere expenses.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *