A sparsely furnished three-room building in West Tisbury marks the unassuming home of Vineyard Power. The organization has two full-time employees: Richard Andre and his assistant, Kerry Downing. All in all it’s a humble arrangement. There is nothing modest, however, about the organization’s ambition. Vineyard Power, the Island’s first energy cooperative, plans to raise and manage nearly $200 million in federal and private investments in wind power and make the Island energy independent within five years.
Energetic, sporty and fastidious, Mr. Andre looks the part of the intrepid start-up entrepreneur. The former chief executive officer of a food and pharmaceutical company in the Netherlands and before that a 15-year employee of British Petroleum knows how to manage a company and earned his stripes in the energy sector. When he moved to the Island four years ago he set to work building what at the time was an unprecedented energy-efficient home, known as a passive house, also building his own personal wind turbine. It wasn’t long before he became involved as a director on the board of the Vineyard Energy Project.
The Vineyard Energy Project was founded in 2003 by renewable energy advocate Kate Warner, a West Tisbury architect, to educate the public on everything from sustainable construction practices to solar panel demonstrations. When the Martha’s Vineyard Commission’s Island Plan called for an electrical cooperative on the Vineyard that could stabilize and lower electric bills for its members while generating renewable energy, members of the Vineyard Energy Project saw an opportunity.
“We saw a lot of recommendations in the Island Plan and said why don’t we take ownership of these and implement them,” says Mr. Andre. After 18 months of work behind the scenes, consulting project managers from similar cooperatives around the globe and devising a workable model for the Vineyard, Vineyard Power was born in November. Since then it’s been a feverish scramble for members and investment dollars. Membership prices are skewed to encourage people to get in now: join today and it’s $50, wait four years and it’s $975. With 400 members already signed up, Mr. Andre says the sales pitch is working.
“The biggest thing for us is the amount of members we have,” he says. “As a community-based organization the more members we have the more credible we are when we’re going for leases against private developers.”
A membership buys a share in the cooperative, and, as shareholders, any profits the cooperative makes would return to them, rather than a third party utility.
The rest of the cooperative’s financing, though, is more complicated. With an estimated $172 million price tag for building 17 offshore wind turbines, membership dues alone will not foot Vineyard Power’s bill. The current plan calls for $82 million to come in the form of a USDA Rural Utilities Service loan, another $57 million from a private equity investor lured by lucrative tax credits, and another $33 million from the sale of renewable energy credits.
Before any of that however, Vineyard Power needs to raise $17 million in predevelopment financing for leasing, permitting, environmental studies and wind monitoring.
“We’ve just begun that process,” says Mr. Andre, “We’re just beginning to get out and meet investors.”
August will mark the first annual meeting of Vineyard Power, during which members will have an opportunity to amend bylaws, elect three new members to the nine-member board of directors and begin to develop criteria for where the location of the turbines.
“That’s why we’re really encouraging people to join because right now we’re getting to the process of making decisions on these things,” Mr. Andre says.
The idea of an energy cooperative may be new to the Vineyard, but it already has proven to be an effective model abroad. The most famous example paraded by renewable energy advocates is the island of Samso in Denmark, which gradually replaced all of the oil and fuel that was shipped to the island — at great expense to both the community and its carbon footprint — with renewable wind energy and biofuels. Delegates at the climate summit in Copenhagen had the opportunity to tour the island in December. A small, mostly agricultural community, Samso made the decision to go off the grid in 1997. In a 2008 New Yorker article Elizabeth Kolbert tracked its success.
“By 2001,” she wrote, “fossil-fuel use on Samso had been cut in half. By 2003, instead of importing electricity, the island was exporting it, and by 2005 it was producing from renewable sources more energy than it was using.”
Samso’s relation to the Vineyard is not merely one of resemblance. Suzanne Slarsky Dael is a consultant to Vineyard Power. She works for the Danish Ministry of Environment and has studied and worked with the island of Samso. Until this past January she lived on the Vineyard helping to get the cooperative off the ground. Mr. Andre says many of the lessons and best practices learned from Samso are now being applied at Vineyard Power. There are, however, important cultural and political gulfs that separate the two Islands.
“The Danish government is very involved in making these things happen. For us the whole regulatory issue and community awareness is a lot farther behind where it is in Europe. The Danish already had, as a culture and a society, bought into the benefits of renewable energy, so that was a fairly easy sell.”
And the models for Vineyard power are not confined to Europe. Vinalhaven, a rural summer colony in Penobscot Bay in Maine, completed work on three land-based wind turbines that will provide enough energy for the entire island in the summer and a surplus that will return benefits to cooperative members in the winter.
“It’s an island with a year-round population that has the same challenges that the year-round population has here in earning a sustainable living in a tough and expensive place to earn a living,” says Mr. Andre, who has been in touch with the Vinalhaven cooperative president George Baker. That project had no state permits, no contract for purchasing turbines and serious financial shortfalls just seven months before its completion, a testament to how quickly such a project can get off the ground.
Mr. Andre envisions a future on the Vineyard where the energy offshore is captured as efficiently as possible. Electric cars in particular fire his imagination.
“Can you think of a better place for them? It’s an Island, you can’t drive over 45 miles per hour. You just connect your car to your home and get the power from the wind,” he says.
In the end, he says, the most important thing is for Islanders to feel as if they have a voice in the fractious and sometimes polarizing battle over offshore wind.
“The whole Cape Wind controversy is that they’re going to build these 150 turbines out there and we’re all going to be impacted by them, but the benefit is perceived to be going elsewhere,” he says. “If we’re going to have turbines and be impacted by them we might as well benefit from them.”
This article appears in February 19, 2010.

Interesting article. I am looking forward to hearing more about this.
As far as Cape Wind is concerned Mr. Andre mentions that ‘perception’ is at the root of the controversy. While this is certainly true to some degree it doesn’t explain the significantly larger role that ignorance plays in defining much of the opposition to Cape Wind.
Whenever I talk to someone about Cape Wind I begin by asking them where our power currently comes from and how it is manufactured. No one I have met has accurately answered that question yet (and I have talked to scores of people)but that doesn’t seem to prevent them from having firmly held beliefs against Cape Wind.
Objections range from the idiotic all the way to the absurd. Many people say they don’t want a private developer to make money without realizing that all energy production comes from private developers now. Some talk about the destruction of the fishery but seem to forget that it is already in complete collapse without a wind farm. Some compare the open body of water to Yellowstone Park but I have never heard of a single person claiming to have come here just to see it. Some talk about ‘pristine beauty’ but ignore the mercury contamination that is a direct result of burning coal.
A significant number of people are concerned only with the cost of electricity produced by wind while ignored all of the other costs and benefits offered by wind /renewable energy.
The list goes on and on.
Let’s face it; we’re naive and spoiled when it comes to energy. The (seemingly) free ride is coming to an end and people don’t want to believe that we need to change.
The main issue with Cape Wind is not private versus public investment. The real issue is cost benefit. The change being proposed here is to force a power bill of approx. $200 per MWhr down onto rate payers (as I write the price of power in New England is $40). Tellingly, you will see this charge not on the energy portion of your bill but as an adder to your T&D.
Each person in MA will be donating approx. $500 to this project – a charity not of our choice. At least the COOP is a choice.
The majority of power in New England comes from natural gas and nuclear power. This facility will not address issues with the dirty 5 plants – most significantly Brayton Point (coal) and Canal (residual fuel and natural gas).
Let us not kid ourselves into thinking Big Brother can create a solution for green energy. Allowing bureaucrats to pander to people’s perceptions is not a solution to any problem.
JP, I agree with you. I do not want to pay $200 per MWhr for electricity. As you said, every person in Massachusetts will be “donating” about $500 to the Cape Wind project. I have greatly reduced my electricity expenses in my house with a few simple measures. My parents both passed away in February and March last year. NSTAR told me that they had been spending about $225 per month on electricity. I inherited their home, and my electric bill is now about $74 per month. How did I do it? First, I stopped using the central air conditioning. I now use the dishwasher only two or three days per week. I keep lights out in unused rooms. I use the cold water setting on my washing machine. And, to save on oil, during my oil burner’s annual cleaning and inspection, I had my hot water heater turned down to a temperature where I am not scalded in the shower. That has reduced my oil bills, as has heating my house to no higher than 68 degrees and turning off the heat completely in April. So, with a few simple conservation steps like these, we can make a difference without resorting to windmills.
I don’t think some of the proponents of industrializing Nantucket Sound have a clear grasp of thier opponents arguments. None of us have a problem with private developers making money from energy generation. We do however strongly disagree with the federal government giving away 26 square miles of our land to a private developer for free. The taxpayers will also provide the developer with hundreds of millions of dollars in tax breaks so that they can provide us our energy at triple the current rate. When you combine the absurdity of this scenario with the statement that tourists do NOT come here to enjoy the beauty of the ocean one must wonder about the sanity of some of the pro-development crowd.
‘Thinker’ is at it again!
He makes the sweeping claim that ‘none’ of the opponents to Cape Wind are against a private developer making money. Really? Did he take some sort of poll to determine this? He goes on to say that Cape Wind will get to use the portion of Nantucket Sound for free. This is not a precondition in any document that I can locate.
As far as tax breaks are concerned: All energy production is currently subsidized.
The last time I looked at my electric bill there was only one rate regardless of which power plant it came from or how it was produced. ISO New England purchases power in a ‘Dutch’ auction format where all sellers (the individual power plants)are paid the exact same rate once the quota is filled, regardless of their cost per KwH. Tax benefits or subsidies to Cape Wind or any other power company are not coming out of ‘Thinker’s’ pocket.
Observer, let me simplify my point for you. What I meant to say was over the last decade or so of attending public hearings, reading literature and listening to debates about the proposed Cape Wind project I have never heard an opponent of the project state they didn’t to see a private developer make a profit. Nor have I seen any document or heard any proposal from Cape Wind that would indicate they are going to pay for the use of Nantucket Sound. As for tax subsidies not coming out of my pocket, where praytell do you think tax dollars come from?? Of course no ADDITIONAL taxes will come out of our pockets if the Federal government reduces its spending in other areas to offset the expected $1.3 billion in tax relief that will be given to Cape Wind. If you believe that, well, enough said.
Mr. Andre and the reporter neglect to recognize the true role of the Vineyard Energy Project and the deicated employees there for bringing the community on board, fundraising, and important political and social networking. VP is not a one man show – if Mr. Andre continues to paint it as such – it’s not going to work. It must be about community, involve community voices not just wealthy board members who can afford to live in passive houses.
I believe in this project – but fear it’s going off track and that I may regret my investment of money and hope.
I guess Thinker and I have gone to two completely different sets of meetings and hearings. My experience is that the private developer making money issue is one of the top five objections I constantly hear.
As far as Thinker’s other point- tax revenues/tax dollars and tax credits are not the same thing.
But since you raised the issue of money let me pose the question; is price per kilowatt hour the only cost you associate with your electricity?
Cape Wind will have to be competitive if they want to sell their power on the open market/auction format.
Island Observer,
You have some knowledge of the New England power system – but it is incomplete and therefore you have some wrong understandings.
In the case of Cape Wind, its marginal cost of $0 will ensure that it runs (given wind). But, due to the state mandated contract it will sign with the MA utilities it will be paid through your T&D portion of your bill. This cost will be about $200 per MW hr. The deal offered by the Governor ensures that the subsidy is a direct and exorbitant tax borne directly from rate payers.
On top of this tax is the tax credits et al that each wind farm can qualify. Not sure how you say that all energy is subsidized.
Right now in New England you can purchase over 7,000 MWs of new combined cycle generation at perhaps 30% the cost to build. It looks to me that the generators are “subsidizing” the consumer. This means that the deal provided to Cape Wind could be used to purchase approx. 5,400 MWs of new gas fired generation.
As home to Filene’s Basement, people of MA should understand that they are shopping at Prada and not Filenes Basement when supporting Cape Wind.
T.E.B is correct in saying that Vineyard Power should be about community, and that it should involve and reflect them. However, to say that we are proceeding without a concern for community involvement is simply wrong. If it appears otherwise it is error of perception not intent. I say this as someone very actively involved in developing the decision process that coop members will use to select a potential site for offshore wind development. It is specifically designed to encourage participation, collaboration, and dialogue among members as well as the community as a whole. The details of this process were outlined to members at our first meeting on February 7th and will be introduced to the community in the weeks to come along with information for how they can participate. I assure you that an enormous amount of energy and intent is being put to the task of creating a forum for direct participation in a matter of great significance to the island. I look forward to your participation.
Hey JP,
Didn´t Filene´s give up the ghost awhile ago?
I suggest you pro development types up in Chilmark put your money where your mouth is. Let a developer come take a chunk of your property- for free of course- subsidize the construction and operation of a wind turbine and let them sell that electricity back to you for at least triple the price. Of course you won’t own the property anymore, or have any claim to the structure or the power created by it. Keep in mind “it’s the vision, not the view”
More specious drivel from the sage of WT, Deep Thinker. I just wonder what drum you are going to beat once Cape Wind is asessed lease fees by the MMS? I’m sure you’ll find one.
And to JP: How will you compute the true cost of electricity when the mercury contamination due to acid rain turns Nantucket Sound into a Superfund cleanup site?
Let’s just pretend everything is o.k. so we can all keep talking about ‘pristine beauty’.
I’d be interested in knowing which coal fired power plants will be shut down once we have Cape Wind up and running? Wait, never mind, I already know the answer, none.
Great reasoning Thinker.
Let’s not deploy renewable wind energy because it won’t close the existing coal fired power plant!
Why not build so many turbines up and down the eastern coast of the USA so ALL the coal fired plants will close?
All powerplants run on an ‘as needed’ basis, adjusting for demand. Every kwhr generated by Cape Wind is one less generated by coal.
I guess we can just do nothing and keep building coal plants to meet the rising demand for energy. There are pending applications for over one hundred in the country, several in New England.
Sounds good, Thinker?
from bdtonline.com
“Dr. James Lovelock, 84 year-old inventor of the “Gaia theory” and inspiration for the green movement, now regrets his endorsement of wind projects in Great Britain, according to Britain’s Western Morning News. Dr. Lovelock points out that wind turbines need conventional fossil fuel-fired power stations backing them up, and those power stations must constantly burn fuel on stand-by so that when the wind stops blowing they can quickly be put online to make up the production slack and meet demand. The major advantage of clean energy technology is that it doesn’t burn fossil fuels, so to have fossil fuel plants fired up on stand-by defeats the primary advantage of wind energy. Dr. Lovelock has termed wind power “an expensive folly.” ”
This comes from a true Global warming believer!!
Hey Thinker-
A week or so ago you were telling us that global warming is total hokum and provided a list of scientists (who coincidentally are paid mouthpieces of the corporate world) to prove it.
Now you are directing our attention to the opinions of a leading global warming scientist.
Does this represent a revelation on your part or are you just cherry picking opinions from whatever camp to bolster you claims?
What next?
Burning fuel to remain in a ‘standby’ mode is nothing compared to what a powerplant like Brayton Point burns when operating at full capacity. Wind cannot ever be our sole source of power. No one ever claimed it would be. But reductions in fossil fuel dependence, less carbon dioxide and fewer heavy metals and pollutants spewing into our environment every minute is not a bad thing in my humble opinion.I also perfer my swordfish and tuna without the mercury. I’m sort of funny that way.
I was merely trying to point out that even one of the High Priests of your religion disagrees with some of the faithful.