Wind, tides and sun are intense subjects for discussion on the Island these days and it’s not all talk about the weather. Alternative energy projects are under way on so many fronts, both private and public, that it is sometimes hard to keep track of them all. But the Vineyard is moving ahead on three projects independently to generate electricity for its own needs, beginning with wind farms.

The deadline for lease bids on a wide swath of the Atlantic ocean south and west of the Island was extended by a month this week following a vocal meeting between state and federal officials and Island fishermen last Thursday. And as the deadline nears, the fledgling Vineyard energy cooperative finds itself pitted against large-scale commercial wind developers. It’s a difficult position, said Vineyard Power director Richard Andre, who now has until the end of March to apply for a plot on the continental shelf. He is urging co-op members and the public at large to pressure the government to give community organizations a seat at the table when it comes time to bid on the 25 lease blocks south of the Vineyard.

“Right now the Feds have not determined how they will distinguish between, let’s say, little Vineyard Power and, let’s say, a company that’s backed by a very large private equity firm that has a lot of money,” Mr. Andre said on Thursday.

He said the government could pursue its traditional “bonus bid” auction process that rewards high bidders, in which case Vineyard Power would be likely shut out, or pursue what is called a “multifactoral process” where community ownership, community benefits and impacts to the local economy would be balanced against a simple monetary bid. The Vineyard Power Web site invites readers to cut and paste a letter in support of the more inclusive process and send it to the federal government. With wind development very near, Mr. Andre said it is time for the Island to rally.

“It’s not this binary discussion anymore about pro-wind, anti-wind,” Mr. Andre said. “If it’s coming why should we not benefit from this? Why should we not get the jobs? Why should we not get the stable energy prices?”

And while the wind farm plans move ahead, another plan is moving forward in Edgartown to harness the power of the tides.

Earlier this month the town of Edgartown filed a notice of intent to file a license application for a pilot tidal energy project in Muskeget Channel. The plan calls for obtaining funding from state, federal and private grants. For the past three years the town, with the help of the University of Massachusetts at Dartmouth, has been involved in a feasibility study of the area that includes measuring currents. This winter the results have been analyzed in preparation for an application to the federal energy regulatory commission. If the application is successful, the next step is installing an underwater turbine of sorts to capture the power of the rushing water.

“The technology is still in the early development stage,” said Kitt Johnson, who is on the Edgartown energy committee. “But when the dust finally settles we stand to be the recipient of a nice little electric generation system out there that, frankly, was paid for by other people.”

He said the success of a full-scale project will depend on the town’s enthusiasm and the success of the pilot, and even if everything goes as planned it could still be more than a decade before the tides run a lightbulb on the Vineyard.

There is also more than one solar project underway, including a joint project between Edgartown and Tisbury in conjunction with the Cape and Vineyard Electric Cooperative, an offshoot of the Cape Light Compact. That project involves building a large array of solar panels over six acres on town-owned land at Katama Farm. Still far from being a done deal, the complicated project involves a lease of land from the town to the electric cooperative, which in turn will lease the property to a private contractor who will bear the cost of building the project. There are still many legal details to complete before bids can be awarded. But Mr. Johnson remains upbeat about the prospects.

“The great thing about this is it’s structured to be a fixed price over the next 20 years . . . We’re not just interested in renewable energy because it’s renewable energy, this has to be a long-term benefit to the town. Even at today’s rates the prices that we’re looking at would save the town half its electric bill,” he said.

Meanwhile, Vineyard power has launched its own solar initiative and hopes to begin construction this summer on at least one project. Through a combination of large commercial projects and smaller residential projects, the cooperative hopes to generate up to a megawatt of solar power. This compares to their plan to generate more than 40 megawatts of electricity — enough to power the entire Island — from 10 offshore wind turbines.

But Mr. Andre said it is important for members to have an immediate return on their membership which the solar project allows them to do. The cooperative’s wind project is expected to take at least five years to develop.

“We’re not just wind developers,” he said. “We want to do a mix of renewable projects as long as it makes economic sense to our members, which solar does.”

Join the Conversation

9 Comments

  1. Where are we talking about for the wind turbines — by tisbury great pond? gay head menemsha? just trying to imagine it.

  2. Just want to point out that it is misleading in your article to say that any offshore wind project will “power the entire island”. The cable from the Vineyard Power project will not come to the island – it will go to the mainland. Even if every one of these offshore wind projects is built, including Vineyard Power, islanders will continue to get their electricity through the same mix of sources we’ve been getting it from all along.

  3. I am saddened that the tone of the debate about wind farms off Martha’s Vineyard is sounding like “it’s a done deal” for wind development. Especially when you have so many folks like joyce, ob who don’t even know about the proposed development. There are no turbines out there yet, and every Vineyarder should be in full protest mode.
    These wind turbines are a sham. Just looking at the corruption behind these developments is enough to sicken me. But then look at the impact to the environment. There has been NO study, that I know of, addressing the impact to the marine life, the fishing industry or largest Right Whale population seen in modern history right off our coast. The BOEMRE is the new name for the MMS which is the Federal body responsible for approving the BP oil rigs.
    The unsightly development will ruin our pristine views. Imagine hundreds if not thousands of towers/turbines 525 feet tall. That’s 210 taller than Prospect Hill and 420 feet taller than the highest point on Cuttyhunk! Go to the cliffs in Aquinnah and look out at Cuttyhunk and Noman’s Land and imagine this view!
    Lastly,the real issue here is how to meet our energy needs. I am hugely opposed to mountain-top removal for domestic coal mining. But at the same time I’m against this ocean-based wind development. The issue is our electricity consumption. We can meet our needs easily with conservation. Somehow, that’s a dirty word to those who seek to profit from these developments. This ocean-based development is a Spruce-Goose. It’s too big, too arcaic, too expensive, and does not “fly” when there is no wind. We can not cash in our beautiful environment willy-nilly, just to meet the supposed demand of our blind, ever-growing consumption. I urge all Vineyarders, especially those who do not really know the facts but are in favor of this development to really seek out the facts. It’s easy to see that we have to fight this. The battle is not over. There is no development yet! Keep our Beautiful Vineyard environment undisturbed for the the fish, birds, whales and yes, even us humans.

  4. Craig,
    Whether we conserve or not our electricity has to come from somewhere . If you are opposed to wind and domestic coal mining, where do you suggest our Island gets its energy from?
    You know what’s ruining my pristine (as defined: In its original condition; unspoiled) view from my window right now? An electricity pole, paved roads, a lighthouse, cars driving, a family of skunks and some fences. Haven’t we gotten used to these? One of them was probably necessary for you to write this feedback.
    As for studies, take a look at what Rhode Island has done in the area of which you speak: http://seagrant.gso.uri.edu/oceansamp/research.html

  5. Craig, you say that you aren’t aware of any studies of wind development on the fishing industry, marine habitat, etc that you are aware of. That strikes me as either extremely odd or rather disingenuous since there is a mountain of data readily available online.
    You also say you are sickened by the corruption going on with these developments. Are you unaware that the Canal Plant in Sandwich which happens to primarily burn high-sulphur crude oil (remember the last two oil spills in Buzzards Bay, Craig?)is owned by a company named Enron. Does that name ring a bell Craig?
    I might suggest that you follow your own advice and seek out the facts, do a bit of research and then determine if your sweeping generalities still hold water.
    I did find one thing to agree with in your post though, conservation is always a great idea.

  6. To reply to “question WT and Bob S., I really have researched this and I used to be in favor of this development. I followed the link “question” posted and it went to a detailed description of studies being done, but no data. I have looked quite a bit Bob, but truly have not found anything but “planned studies”. Please post links to the mountain of data you speak of. I do want to see it. Here on Maui there is a successful land-based wind farm that produces 800,000 diesel barrels-worth of power per year. For the last 3 weeks the turbines have barely turned at all. Yes question, the power does come from somewhere and it’s brought to us by ugly wires and roads. The dirty fossil fuels provide huge amounts of power and we freely consume it. Our huge Truck/Suv/Power-cars zoom around getting a low 20-+ mpg while the Gulf of Mexico gushes crude. There are huge amounts of power available. The amount of power proposed to be provided by this development is significant in many ways and comes at great costs. Will this project actually reduce our fossil-fuel useage? I doubt it. Will the planet be actually cared for by using difficult-to-obtain heavy metals and alloys to build these machines (in China…)? When will they offset thier impact?
    The power industry is dirty and corrupt indeed. But we do business with it everyday. We probably have ownership in these same companies thru our retirement accounts. The idea of Transitioning our power consumption to non-fossil fuel-based is a grand, noble and wise idea.I’m in favor of that effort. This off-shore wind farm idea is huge, and the environmental impacts are huge. What will our return be? So far I hear of very high prices. I also hear of the pollution involved in manufacturing the machines. I see obvious corruption and hurrying of the process. We have to hear all sides, and right now I have heard enough reasons to be opposed to this development. Please show how this project will benefit anyone other than those profiting financially. Please show how the environmental impacts are addressed and mitigated. But more importantly, how will the Vineyard benefit from cashing in it’s (almost)un-developed beauty into the World’s Largest Industrial Off-Shore Wind-Power Factory. Again I ask, go to the ocean at The Cliffs in Aquinnah and ask yourself to imagine that factory out there. Then imagine how the Right Whales might feel…

  7. Hello back Craig.
    There isn’t enough space here to address all of the points you raise but I am happy to meet with you when you are I are back on Island.
    I still find many aspects of your reasoning process highly specious. Talking about the pollution caused by MANUFACTURING wind turbines! Isn’t that a bit of a stretch? Or the ‘hurried process’? Cape Wind is in its tenth year of permitting. Here in Nicaragua, the Amayo wind farm went online after roughly eighteen months and is already producing roughly 6% of the electricity for the entire country!
    Do you still maintain that wind turbines ‘are just a sham’?
    I look forward to a more in depth discussion with you in the coming months.
    Meanwhile, if you can provide some documentation on turbine damage to right whales please post it.

  8. Let’s ask the Right Whale community how they felt about the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.

    Scroll about 3/4 of the way down and click on Cape Wind Final Environmental Impact Statement for 800 pages of data.
    http://www.boemre.gov/offshore/RenewableEnergy/CapeWind.htm

  9. Bob – no, talking about manufacturing turbines is not a stretch. It is the most steel and concrete intensive form of energy per kwhr there is, and as you must know, steel and concrete are some of the most energy intensive products to create. What is more, each turbine requires 1-3 tons of rare earth minerals PER TURBINE. Not only is the mining of rare earths extremely energy intensive, but it is also very polluting and causes radioactive waste. Please read this article to educate yourself more about this:
    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1350811/In-China-true-cost-Britains-clean-green-wind-power-experiment-Pollution-disastrous-scale.html

    Now China is planning on limiting its exports of rare earths, so a mine in America that was formerly shut down due to radioactive leakage will now reopen to produce rare earths in California.

    As far as the whales are concerned, it is indeed a concern. Please read this article for more info on the impact of ocean development from windfarms on whales:
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/energy/windpower/8382476/Wind-farms-blamed-for-stranding-of-whales.html?sms_ss=email&at_xt=4d7f4f331be8a05c,0

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *