A New Hampshire attorney and former county commissioner from the Granite State was selected this week as the next Dukes County manager. But Katherine Rogers told the Gazette yesterday that she is still deciding whether to take the job.

Katherine Rogers.
Katherine Rogers.

“I am very seriously considering it,” Ms. Rogers said. “It’s a great honor and it’s thrilling that they would offer me the job.” She said she expects to make her final decision within the next seven days.

At a special meeting Wednesday, the Dukes County Commission voted 5 to 2 to offer her the position. If she does take the job, Ms. Rogers, a former county attorney serving Merrimack County, N.H., will relocate to the Island from Concord, N.H.

In the event that Ms. Rogers does not accept the position, the county commission is expected to reassess the other finalists.

“We will go back to the remaining candidates and open up a discussion,” said commission chairman Melinda Loberg yesterday.

Ms. Rogers, currently a lawyer in private practice, served as county attorney in Merrimack, N.H. for three years. She also served as a Merrimack County commissioner from 2001 to 2009. Ms. Rogers was the only off-Island candidate. She was also one of two candidates who wrote thank you letters following their interview with the county commissioners, which took place last week.

“She will bring a lot of know-how to the job,” Ms. Loberg said. “She is a seasoned veteran, a person who has had a lot of experience.”

Not all commissioners were on board with the decision and there was heated debate before the vote. Commissioners John Alley and Tristan Israel opposed the motion to select Ms. Rogers. Mr. Israel voiced concern that her current off-Island residence made her unsuitable for the position. “The history on the board of bringing someone from off-Island has been spotty,” Mr. Israel said. “She has impressive credentials, but I hope we’re not making a big mistake.”

Others took a different view. “This borders on ‘Irish need not apply,’ ” said county commissioner Leonard Jason Jr. “We agreed to go out and get the best person for this job.”

Under the county charter, the county manager must live on the Island. “There are going to be some risks involved with every candidate,” Ms. Loberg said. “We asked this candidate many times [about moving to the Island], and the answer was always in the affirmative,” she said. “This person overcame the deficit of not living here which tells me people are able to see something really remarkable about her.”

Commissioners who voted to offer Ms. Rogers the position were Carlene Gatting, Melinda Loberg, Thomas Hallahan, Leonard Jason, Jr. and Beth Toomey.

“Katherine Rogers’s level of expertise, knowledge, presentation, demeanor and references were all stellar,” Ms. Gatting said. “[Her] whole package rose significantly above the other candidates.”

Thomas Hallahan said he was most impressed by Ms. Rogers’s answer to the interview question, where do you want to see the county in five years? “Ms. Rogers was the only candidate who said, that’s not my job, it’s your job,” he said, referring to the commissioners. “She didn’t miss a question. It was right off the top of her head.”

The five finalists were Christopher Knowles, health director for the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah); Martina Thornton, current executive assistant to the county manager; Jessica Burgoyne, property manager for the Morgan Woods affordable housing development; and Jeffrey Madison, an attorney on the Island.

Three commissioners chose Ms. Rogers as their top candidate, while two chose Mrs. Thornton. Jessica Burgoyne and Jeffrey Madison were ranked third.


Mr. Alley said he favored Martina Thornton, the current executive assistant, because she knew the political body best. “I voted for Martina because she has been our leader . . . we need someone who already knows the players,” Mr. Alley said.

The county budget allows for an annual salary of $63,500. The job description calls for expertise managing a budget, writing grants and communicating with other government leaders. The previous county manager, Russell Smith, resigned May 1 after holding the position for four years. Noreen Flanders, county treasurer, has been serving as interim county manager.

There were 19 applications for the position. The five finalists were interviewed publicly last week.

Join the Conversation

5 Comments

  1. I totally agree with washashorefor59years!
    Also I think every commissioner who voted for Ms Rogers should be encouraged not to run for reelection especially their chairperson! This is not only a disgrace and a terrible embarrassment but they have given another reason to abolish our county government.
    Questions to be pubically answered by the commissioners; IF she was to take the job not knowing a soul on MV where does she plan to find a yearround place to stay or buy this time of year, Why have the citizens done a better Google quick search job on her when doing a backround check, Why did it look like on TV that they tried to have a illegal secret ballot voting process?
    I agree with Mr Alley and washashorefor59years! when they said Martina should get the job but that is to logical I guess.
    I am looking forward to the next issue of the Gazette to read that Rogers did not accept the job and I cant wait to hear her reasons why!
    I will also look forward to the League of Woman Voters Candidates night to ask the commissioners the above questions.

  2. As someone who has known Katherine Rogers for many years, let me state that Dukes County would be lucky to have her as its manager. She is someone with great integrity, intelligence and a work ethic that is second to none. If she does choose to accept the job, I do not doubt that she has the resourcefullness to find lodging and the adaptability to fit in to her new job with grace.

    I only hope that the reader feedback thus far does not reflect the kind of reception she will receive from the majority of islanders. Martha’s Vineyard has always held a piece of my heart.. my sister was married on South Beach and my husband and I honeymooned on the island. I have bicycled from Vineyard Haven to Aquinnah and back many times. My favorite vacation memories are all of MV. Every islander I’ve met has been warm and welcoming. I hope this same hospitality will be extended to Ms. Rogers if she indeed accepts the position of Dukes County Manager.

  3. From NH – you missed the point
    No one said Ms Rogers wasn’t a fine upstanding person, the problem is she’s thinking about it.
    It was the Commissioners job to only select the most serious candidates who were absolutely committed to taking the job. Not, wow now that I have the job let me think about it..
    Blow me away!!
    Also, how could Ms Rogers be as familiar with the Island and it’s needs as a true resident.
    I smell a long learning curve with alot of guidance ahead.

  4. Washashorefor59years, my understanding of the process is that the MVC was looking for the best person for the job, not the best islander for the job. From what I’ve read, you’ve had several managers in the not so distant past who have been from the island. How did they work out?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *