The Chilmark Community Center will continue under the same leadership for the upcoming summer after months of debate.
The select board Tuesday unanimously picked the Chilmark Town Affairs Council (CTAC), which has been running the center’s programming since 1959, to continue operating at the town-owned facility for the next three years. The nonprofit beat out the Chilmark Community Center Trust, a recently formed group that sought to take over operations in the wake of concerns about CTAC.
Select board members graded the proposals from the two entities and rated CTAC’s as 94 per cent highly advantageous while Chilmark Community Center Trust scored 31 per cent highly advantageous.
“Both [organizations] reflect a deep commitment to our children and to the future of the CCC summer program,” select board chair Marie Larsen said. “Anyone who reads [the proposals] will immediately see how much heart and effort went into each one. The select board is asked to make a very difficult choice between these two strong and thoughtful proposals.”
The management of the center has been a point of contention in the town for years. During the annual town meeting in 2024, a committee was created to examine the center’s procedures and programming after threats to split the tennis program from the other activities.
The committee released a 142-page report last year, which kicked off the process of creating the request for proposals from different groups. The select board started working on the request for proposals draft in October.
In their proposals, both organizations gave detailed operational plans and required policies, with slight variations in the programming options.
CTAC’s executive summary emphasized the organization’s long history with the center and the surrounding community.
“For nearly 70 years, the Chilmark Town Affairs Council (CTAC) has supported the Town of Chilmark in fostering community programming at the Chilmark Community Center (CCC), where year-round and summer residents meet, play, and connect,” the summary reads.
The Chilmark Community Center Trust said its highest priority is responding to the community’s needs.
“Over the past six months we have listened to over 200 residents through public meetings, one-on-one conversations, parent outreach, parking lot and porch chats, and advisory group forums. This diversity of voices shaped our proposal, which prioritizes a return to the ‘Chilmark spirit’ that people miss and value dearly,” the summary reads.
Members of CTAC are grateful to the select board for awarding the proposal to them and they said they hope to bring the community together after a tumultuous couple of years.
“We have done a lot of listening and we believe in community and we want community to come together and that it’s incumbent on all of us to build community,” CTAC chair Michelle O’Connor said.
Executive director Susan Andrien added there have been leadership changes in order to better refelect the community the center serves.
“We have expanded our board and the majority of our board is year-round residents,” she said. “We’ve worked hard to bring representation of the town of Chilmark onto the board that care very deeply and have been an integral part of thinking about where we’re going with this next phase with CTAC and the community center.”
While the Chilmark Community Center Trust is disappointed at the decision, the group is planning on continuing to help strengthen the community, co-chair Nathaniel Scott said.
“One of our main goals is seeing the community coming back together. The decision has been made and we want to be a productive group for Chilmark,” he said. “We want to still help with any other programming that can help the community. We’ll be looking to see how we can work productively with [CTAC].”
A last-minute concern was brought up by the Chilmark Community Center Trust, as lawyers representing the organization said that CTAC’s bylaws did not include a community-based nominating committee as required by the request for proposals.
The select board then went to town counsel, and the town counsel said that the omission wasn’t consequential enough to disqualify CTAC’s proposal.
“We believe that the issues above are minor and clearly a mistake, and that causing their corrections post award but prior to execution of an agreement would not cause prejudice to any party,” select board Matt Poole said at the meeting, reading a letter sent by town counsel.
Ms. Larsen thanked the community for its hard work throughout the process.
“I think we should all take a moment to recognize and appreciate the tremendous amount of work that has brought us here,” she said. “I hope we can accept this decision in the spirit of which was made, with respect, goodwill and a shared commitment to our town and our children. Our children deserve nothing less.”
This article appears in January 23, 2026.
