re_katama_meadows_012326_006
The subdivision is proposed to donate 14 lots to the town. - Ray Ewing

The Edgartown select board this week requested the Martha’s Vineyard Commission not impose income-based restrictions for part of a controversial housing development plan. 

In a letter sent to the MVC sent on Monday, the select board wrote it has “serious concerns” that fixed income restrictions on the Katama Meadows development proposal’s town-owned lots would limit Edgartown’s ability to meet housing needs. Plans for the subdivision are currently under commission review. 

“The town remains committed to ensuring these lots are used to advance year-round housing objectives and believes it is best positioned to determine how to do so effectively as conditions evolve,” the letter wrote.

Katama Meadows is a 54-acre subdivision proposal off Meeting House Way put forth by Utah-based developers Douglas Anderson and Richard Matthews. The project was formerly known as Meeting House Way and has undergone several redesigns.

The most recent proposal includes 26 market-rate lots and designates 12 year-round homesite lots for people making up to 250 per cent of the Dukes County area median income. It would also donate 14 lots to the town with income restrictions that have yet to be determined.

In the letter, the board wrote that MVC-imposed deed restrictions of below 150 per cent of the area median would interfere with the town’s intent to meet housing needs for municipal workers and the “missing middle” population, a growing group of residents who earn too much to be eligible for affordable housing but not enough to afford a home on-Island. The select board wanted the flexibility to determine income restrictions as market conditions and workforce demands change.

Select board member Art Smadbeck said a low turnout of applicants for townhouses at the Meshacket Commons development was a reason the town requested flexibility. 

“We had people who were interested but they didn’t qualify because of the income restriction, and that’s one of the reasons that we wanted to do this,” said select board member Art Smadbeck.

One of the Meshacket Commons townhouses was restricted at 120 per cent area median income with a municipal employee preference, but saw no municipal employee applicants. The board wrote the outcome indicates that moderate area median income thresholds are not viable for missing middle households. 

The board wrote it has previously had municipal control throughout other programs, which is critical to achieving successful outcomes for missing middle households.

The MVC will continue its public hearing on the Katama Meadows proposal Thursday at 6:30 p.m. 

5 replies on “Edgartown Asks for Right to Set Restrictions on Katama Meadows Lots”

  1. The Edgartown select board is right to seek flexibility from the Martha’s Vineyard Commission, as doing nothing with the Katama Meadows lots may be better than imposing a 14-lot cluster with rigid income restrictions.

    Fixed caps tied to area median income could exclude the very “missing middle” residents the project claims to support. Overly restrictive requirements risk limiting demand and failing to meet real housing needs.

    Allowing the McCarron model missing middle lots to be sold without added constraints would better reflect market realities and local priorities.

    This proposal is nearly identical to earlier versions that faced strong opposition. In the most recent DRI residents submitted 40 letters to the MVC opposing it, and in the previous DRI with virtually the same plan, they submitted over 80. Given that consistent public concern, the board’s cautious and flexible approach is justified.

  2. Nice to see some forward thinking out of the selectman and totally agree with Art. We absolutely need more missing middle housing.

  3. It’s good to recognize that there are people who earn more than 150% AMI and still have trouble affording to buy a house, but this trend in emphasizing the “missing middle” over traditional affordable housing is starting to go to far. First of all, “the middle” is 100% AMI, by definition. Half the people earning income from working jobs make less than that, and they need somewhere to live too. Second, it’s fair to say 150% AMI, about $225K for a family, is still part of the middle. But is 300K? Almost 400K? That’s what 200% and 250% AMI come to if you use the Dukes Co Housing chart (just google it). Third, if people earning that much need help affording housing, how in the world are people earning an average salary supposed to afford anything at all? Finally, if we’re supplying subsidized housing for our highest earners, who’s paying for it?

  4. What Edgartown and the island doesn’t need is developers from Utah building 26 market rate homes on the last 50 acres of open space abutting Edgartwon Great pond watershed. Thanks to the MV commission for over seeing and hopefully denying this project, again.

    1. Would you be in favor if it was a local developer or if you were hired by the ‘utah’ developers to do the construction? Just asking for a friend.

Comments are closed.