re_beetlebung_baking_and_milling_matt_pontarelli_filling_the_milling_machine_030526_041
Matt Pontarelli fills the milling machine. - Ray Ewing

It’s simple, really. Grain goes in, flour comes out.

Simple, says Matt Pontarelli, head baker at Beetlebung Farm. Just unfamiliar.

While most bakeries start their breadbaking with flour bought in bulk, Beetlebung starts with grain. It arrives in fifty-pound sacks from regional and local farmers and is processed with the farm’s very own stone mill, producing the whole-grain flours that make up their distinct loaves.

“We have direct relationships with the people that are growing our grain,” said Mr. Pontarelli, who has run the milling program since it started in 2024. “It’s taking farm-to-table to levels that you’re constantly trying to push. You’re creating new expectations for bread.”

Among those expectations is sustainability: reducing waste, building soil health, and supporting a local food system, said Amy Weinberg, co-owner of Beetlebung Farm. The 5.7 acre farm in the heart of Chilmark has been growing and selling fresh produce for decades, managed under the Fischer family before Ms. Weinberg and her husband purchased the property in 2018. Their new farmstand sells local goods, their own produce and whole-grain baked goods.

“The mill is a critical link for us in achieving our goal of honoring the farmer and land from which our food comes,” said Ms. Weinberg.

Take the farm’s Island loaf. The honey comes from Chilmark, the salt from MV Sea Salt. The grain is turkey red wheat and rye from Dan Sternbach, a grain farmer on the Vineyard. It’s milled at Beetlebung, in the space below their farmstand and bakeshop.

The mill, from New American Stone Mills in Vermont, is made of two heavy, grooved granite disks sharpened twice a year. The disks move in opposite directions, crushing grain between the opposing surfaces.

Mr. Pontarelli mills flour in the mornings, keeping an eye on it with a baby camera as he bakes the loaves for the day. He adjusts the distance between the stones based on how hard or soft a grain is — the disks must never grind against each other, which can deteriorate the stone. That’s where the baby camera comes in (and the “terrible” smell of burnt stone, he says).

“It gets more intuitive as time goes on, but really it’s very elemental, it’s very tactile,” said Mr. Pontarelli about the milling process. “You can hear it, you can smell it. At the end of the day if what comes out looks like flour — great, I’m good.”

Most commercial flour is produced with a roller mill, according to Andrew Heyn, co-owner of New American Stone Mills. Roller mills have two corrugated steel rollers that peel apart the grain layer by layer, stripping away the nutrient-packed outer bran and inner germ. What’s left is the endosperm, the protein and starch that is functional for breadbaking.

In other words: white flour.

“Roller mills are about separation…whereas stone milling is about inclusion,” said Mr. Heyn. “The whole wheat berry goes in and the whole wheat flour comes out.”

Stone milling keeps the “good stuff” — the bran and the germ, said Mr. Pontarelli. Besides being packed with fiber, fats and vitamins, the bran and germ contribute to the flour’s aroma and flavor.

Mr. Pontarelli opens a big white bin in the milling room filled with Glenn hard red spring wheat, ground into flour. It is flecked with brown, which is the bran.

“I think it smells like crushed tomatoes,” said Mr. Pontarelli.

Using the whole product is often a feature of sustainable food systems, and a key component of the Beetlebung ethos. That means when carrots go into salads, carrot tops go into pesto, and the entire pig gets butchered, from the filets to the organs and the feet.

It’s a matter of respect for farmers and their products, said Mr. Pontarelli.

“For years, this whole nose-to-tail cooking has been a thing — using every part of the pig,” said Mr. Pontarelli, who used to work in fine dining. “It’s the same thing with this: we’re using every part of the grain. We’re not wasting the majority of this grain, this beautiful product that a farmer labored over. We’re going to use all of it.”

Grain farming in the Northeast is not new, but like the ancient process of stone milling, it’s unfamiliar in today’s day and age. Grain was an important export in colonial times, allowing New England to supply its own food, said Mr. Sternbach. Blights and exhausted soils eventually caused the market to collapse, and grain production shifted to the fertile lands of the Midwest.

But a re-emerging grain economy in New England, driven largely by small-scale farmers, is increasing the region’s capacity to provide its own food once again. With more commodity-type storage crops and carbohydrates, local food systems become comprehensive. Mr. Sternbach himself started growing grain on the Island just over 10 years ago.

“I was eating a lot of food from the Island, and I realized that tomatoes and lettuce were not gonna cut it,” he said. “I think a lot of people came to the same conclusion around the same time. That’s why you see small-scale grain growers around New England more and more.”

The ability to mill locally at a farm or a bakery supports that regional grain economy. Mills add value to farms, said Mr. Heyn. Since it started, New American Stone Mills has sold over 265 mills to farms and bakeries across the United States, Europe and even in Australia.

For Beetlebung, the ability to mill allows the agricultural product to shine in the final loaf, at once a test of creativity and a testament to a grain’s complexity, said Ms. Weinberg.

Some loaves are made with a blend of flours. Others are single-sourced, highlighting the grain from a single farm. You can taste the difference: a nutty sweetness from Einkorn wheat, an ancient grain, in the Einkorn loaf; a chocolatey robustness from toasted rye in the Island loaf; the creamy texture from Mr. Sternbach’s oats, cooked and folded into a wheat dough for “Dan’s Oat Porridge” loaf.

That same variability can be a challenge. Bakers must navigate the unpredictable yields and flavors of sustainably grown grain, subject to crop failures, soil changes and pre-harvest wheat sprouting. But it’s worth it, said Abbie White, co-owner of Whitesfields Farm, one of Beetlebung’s grain suppliers.

“Something made with truly fresh flour is very, very different than a container of flour that’s been sitting a few weeks or months on a supermarket shelf,” said Ms. White. “They’re just completely different products. One is alive.”

There’s also a resiliency to the local grain and milling industry that makes up for its challenges, said Mr. Heyn. During the pandemic’s baking craze, high demand and halts to shipping meant store shelves were empty of flour. Meanwhile, Mr. Heyn had eight tons of grain in his mill house.

“People were calling us left and right saying, ‘Hey, can we get some of that flour?’” he recalled. “It usually costs more to buy locally-produced flour, but there’s resiliency in that we were able to…get flour to people more quickly than big industrial companies could.”

To introduce others to the Beetlebung ethos of breadbaking, the farm is hosting a series of classes starting in April. Mr. Pontarelli will demonstrate milling and discuss baking with different grains, helping people perfect their very own whole-grain sourdough loaves.

“There’s a fear factor at the beginning of milling and baking bread,” said Mr. Pontarelli. “It’s an art form, but it’s also a process that’s been around for 10,000 years.”

“You’re literally just putting stones together and crushing grain,” he said. “It really is that simple.”

More pictures. 

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *