Paul Laliberte and I were sitting North-South, with no one vulnerable and East dealing, in an OK Bridge tournament:
NORTH (Kaplan)
♠️ 8
♥️ K 10 3
♦️ K J 10 2
♣️ A Q 7 6 5
WEST EAST
♠️ J 10 7 2 ♠️ K 3
♥️ Q 7 ♥️ 9 8 6 5 4 2
♦️ Q 7 5 ♦️ A 9 4 3
♣️ J 10 4 2 ♣️ 9
SOUTH (Laliberte))
♠️ A Q 9 6 5 4
♥️ A J
♦️ 8 6
♣️ K 8 3
The bidding proceeded as follows:
East South West North
Pass 1♠️ Pass 2♣️
2♥️! 2♠️ Pass 3NT
Pass Pass DBL 4♦️
Pass 5♣️ All Pass
Opening lead: ♥️9
I was fooled twice: first, by East’s silly heart overcall; second by West’s double asking for a heart lead. Panicking, I fled to 4♦️, which partner corrected to 5♣️. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that we held four heart honors!
After winning the opening lead with my ♥️K, I played the ♥️3 to the ♥️A, cashed the ♣️K and led the ♣️3 to the ♣️A, discovering the bad trump break.
Figuring West had at least three hearts, I played the ♥️10 to … West’s ♣️10 ruff. Then West led the ♣️J to my ♣️Q.
I finessed the ♠️Q, cashed the ♠️A, and ruffed the ♠️9 with my ♣️6. Here’s where I lost it. Stuck in my hand, I numbly played the unprotected ♦️K to East’s ♦️A. I managed to ruff the ♥️8 return; but then, I played the ♦️J to the ♦️Q. The defenders also picked up the ♠️J. Down two.
Even if you can find a way to make 5♣️, there’s no reason to be in it: 3NT makes easily with four clubs, three hearts, and two spades. If I let the defenders break diamonds, there’s probably a trick there, too. So why didn’t I leave well enough alone at 3NT?
“If you make a principled decision, stick by it,” Paul said, in advice that extends beyond the bridge table.
Amazing how bridge teachses citizenship in addition to everything else.
This article appears in June 19, 2020.
