obit_will_holtham
Will Holtham.

William Dean Holtham died at his home in Kingfield, Me., on Sept. 10. He was 71.

Affectionately known to many by his nickname Willy D., he was a force of nature, a live wire, a big guy with an even bigger heart. Sadly, that heart suddenly stopped beating, but the stories and memories are never-ending, unforgettable and sometimes even unbelievable.

Will was born in Winsted, Conn., on Jan. 15, 1949 to Vinson and Millicent Holtham.

He graduated from the Carson Long Military Academy before attending Ohio State College and then Wentworth Institute of Technology. He played football and ran track where he earned the nickname “the mighty burner.”

He fondly recounted stories of working at and managing Valleys Steak House, Anthony’s Pier 4 and the Cummaquid Restaurant, before owning and operating his beloved Home Port Restaurant in Menemsha in 1977, followed by the Bite and Square Rigger Restaurant.

Will began working at the Home Port under former owner Chet Cummens, washing dishes and mopping floors, followed by years of hard work and tons of fun. His favorite part was making people happy with his cooking, he said, describing his time at the restaurant as part of his fulfilled American dream.

He was a generous man with a passion for cooking, eating, entertaining, teaching and bringing people together. Under his guidance lasting friendships and extended families were formed and generations of employees developed an unrivaled work ethic. When not working in the kitchen or playing a prank, he could be found playing golf, fishing, hunting or reclining in his favorite chair watching the New England Patriots, or searching for the next piece of Yellow Ware on the internet. He could also be seen fearlessly darting around or into trees on his snowmobile through the backwoods of Maine, mapping out his plans the night before on what trails to ride.

He is survived by his wife of 28 years, Madeline Holtham; two daughters, Jessica Bradlee, and Megan Bliss and her husband Eli; a son, Michael Holtham and his wife Jessie; four grandchildren, Parker Bradlee, Jolene and Margot Holtham and Harper Bliss. He is also survived by his sister Judy Giegler (whom he would no doubt like to razz just one more time), two nieces and a nephew.

If you find a piece of blue sea glass on Menemsha Beach think of him — as he would say, it’s a thing of beauty, guy. Willy was “mahvelous,” as he would often say in the kitchen, and will be missed tremendously.

Donations can be made to the local food pantry or the Martha’s Vineyard Fisherman’s Preservation Trust.

A celebration of life will announced and held at a later date.

Join the Conversation

9 Comments

  1. Since my Father was the main electrician, for the HomePort back when Will owned it. I called one day and spoke to Will about getting a job and he told me to show up @ 9:30am the next day. I had never worked in a kitchen before and was also 15 years old and my experience was lacking at the time.

    I ended up working on the day crew under the management of Rodney Bucker and Will as the owner. The day crew ended up taking me in and we all became a family, with Will being the impulsive, fun Father. The environment was amazing and Will as the owner made the environment an extremely fun one. I being the youngest of the crew at the time, definitely had my share of hazing and ridiculous things done to me.Will became a special person in my life and with his help and the day crew. Helped to mold me into the man that I am today and Will, will always hold a special place in my heart.

    I was dubbed the name Bobby-Baru among a lot of others, but that one seemed to stick and I still get called that today. Will, will always be remembered and he’ll be truly missed..Bobby-Baru.

    1. I was also a member of the Homeport day crew in the mid-1980s under Rodney and Will. Truly a wonderful time and I don’t think there was better summer job to be had anywhere. The whole Homeport crew was like family, as you point out, and Will was just as you described. I still talk of those days and the adventure it was for a kid in his late teens. I am very sorry to hear of Will’s passing, he was such a fair, caring and compassionate man.

    2. I hope that losing Will brings people together, whether they knew him or not. Actually, his love and energy with so enormous, I know it will.

    3. WOW!! Bobby-Baru a blast from the legendary day crew of the 90’s, I use to delivery seafood to you guys. I just remember driving over there and seeing all you guys and especially Will. Having a huge water fight with Will yelling out for me, to grab Baru, so they could get you soaked and thrown into the green pond. You don’t have bosses like that anymore or day crews; I remember TJ Barnes, Sam Clappe, Lesley and Lovie as well. That day crew was made up of such unique characters; it was one of the best spots to deliver seafood to. I’d usually get to partake in the antics and it was just awesome. Will new how to have fun and get things done at the same time and make you feel welcome. Rest in Peace Will!!

  2. Like so many others, Will gave me one of my first jobs. And while I’m quite sure I wasn’t the best employee he ever had, he was a great sport and a great influence. All these years later, news of his passing brought a tear to my eye. I managed to get a picture of the flag at the Homeport at half mast, and will always remember him fondly. My condolences and kindest regards to his family and friends.

  3. Love you Will! I can hear you and mom laughing and plotting something along with Mike Lynch! The best of times!You gave our family many years of treasured friendship! Soar high Will and watch over your beautiful children! Always in our hearts!

  4. I met Will when I was a waitress at Valley’s steak house in Chestnut Hill, Ma. I think that would have been 1973 or 1974. We laughed a lot and fell in love. Our relationship lasted about 2 years I think, then we both moved on. We have kept sporadically in touch over the years; he showed off his beloved Homeport to me one summer and he visited me in San Francisco when I lived out there. Mostly it’s just been Christmas cards and facebook.
    I have always wondered what if… But I know he made the right moves in his romantic life and had 3 beautiful children and Madeline was the ONE for him. He was blessed.
    I’m so sad to learn of his passing and wished I could have seen him one more time.
    He was such a GOOD guy, very even tempered and easy to be with. He was kind and a loyal friend. I will miss knowing he’s out here in Maine. RIP Will.

  5. I want to hear from my friends … Will’s kitchen crew … because Will forged a brotherhood with us. We all know it. And we’re all lucky for it. I want a sit down.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *