If you look in my closet at work, you will find, amongst the banker boxes, old posters, brochures and computer keyboards circa 1990, two small plastic bags of black rubber pieces. Some of the pieces are shredded and some have paint on one side. They look like trash, and they are trash, but the journey the material in the bags made to end up in my office, crushed into a corner, was an expensive and long one.
The journey involved two semi-trucks, 200 gallons of diesel, two trips across a body of water, hundreds of emails, big opinions based on little facts, years of nasty debates on Islanders’ Talk and lots of taxpayer dollars. This sounds like a riddle, and so too, I’ve discovered, is how we have decided to conduct most environmental discussions and deliberations on this Island.
Back to the bags of crumb rubber in my closet. The material comes from a “pour-in-place” (PIP) surface. This slightly buoyant mat is a popular surface around the perimeter of jungle gyms, promising lower maintenance costs, a more consistent playing surface and less risk of serious injury. At first glance, it sounds great — no sand in your shoes or mulch splinters. It’s fun to jump on and you can paint the game of four-square right onto it. It even has a cute tagline, “from waste to play value.”
The use of rubber crumb in synthetic surfaces has been around since the 1970s, during the big recycling boom, when industry realized it could monetize its waste to consumers by marketing it as “recyclable.” The recycled rubber used in these surfaces is often factory-mold rubber, but it can also include “tire crumb,” which is crushed-up old automotive tires.
A 2019 Yale study outlined the dangers of the material: “Crumb rubber contains or emits chemicals that can affect human physiology. Of the 306 chemicals associated with crumb rubber infill from publications, application of an in-silico computational program predicted 197 carcinogens. Of these, a total of 52 had been classified as carcinogens by the US EPA and/or the ECHA.”
In layman’s terms, probably best not to let a bunch of young kids, whose developing bodies are more sensitive to toxins, play around every day for years on a surface made up of the stuff.
In light of this study and other studies linking soccer players on rubber turf fields to higher cancer rates, the general public began to ask: Is this safe?
But before this widespread concern about synthetic surfaces, specifically those made with crumb rubber, swept the nation and prompted an EPA study into the material, the West Tisbury School was in the process of installing a new playground.
The surface was marketed to the school as durable and ADA-compliant. It would probably last more than 15 years; it was safe and free of toxic chemicals, and once it needed to be replaced, the school was assured it could be easily recycled.
Despite the marketing ploy, parents and community members immediately voiced environmental and health concerns. Some of these parents would go on to form The Field Fund, a local group advocating for grass playing fields over synthetic ones. The concerns focused on potential exposure students would have to the toxic material, especially when it was sitting directly under the sun. Also, there was a lack of research into regulations since the material was not, at the time, regulated as a children’s product. Additional environmental considerations flagged by The Field Fund included the fact that the school playground area is located within “Zone 1 of the wellhead protection area, which provides the school’s drinking water. Even organic fertilizer cannot be applied to the abutting recess field due to the proximity to the wellhead and the possibility of contamination.”
Despite these concerns, the school was assured by the manufacturer that the surface would be made of ground automotive factory molds, not tires, and that it was completely safe and would be a long-lasting solution. They moved forward with installation and the material was delivered that summer in a semi-truck and installed by heating the black rubber, sloshing it into wheelbarrows to the playground, and pouring it to set.
Before long, the surface began disintegrating under the sun, under little sneakers and sweaty palms. Multiple “sinkholes” in the surface emerged, requiring repairs by off-Island contractors who were delayed for months. The loose rubber fill spilled out, tempting children to play with it, to put it in their mouths.
In 2022, a Field Fund letter reiterated previously voiced concerns and clarified that “although it was marketed as durable, the surface continues to break down. The holes opening up pose an immediate safety risk to users and expose young children and the environment to loose and potentially dangerous materials.
And the original “light” color chosen to “reflect the heat rather than heat up” has long since worn off.” Included in the letter were pictures of three surface temperature readings in June, one showing temperatures of 148 degrees, double the air temperature.
In early 2024, a playground inspector tested the surface and found that it was close to failing drop tests in several important areas, and was “pebbling” (shedding tiny rubber crumbs everywhere) on the playground equipment, the neighboring sandbox area, the outskirts of the woods. Finally, only eight years after installation, it was decided that the surface should be removed.
The surface was torn up in a hot July of that year and loaded into another semi-truck, all but the thousands of small rubber beads that had migrated all over the playground, into the woods and waterways and across the Island on the soles of tiny sneakers. The material traveled another 1,200 miles in a semi-truck before being left at a dump outside a town in rural mid-coast America, where the median income is likely 25 per cent of our Island’s population.
The surface was not durable; it was not recyclable. What else was a lie?
I began shadowing the project during its removal. I looked into testing the three bags of material that The Field Fund had saved from the surface. Wouldn’t that be a simple end to the saga and perhaps inform our decision-making moving forward? Nothing like conclusive scientific data to put an end to it.
I emailed professors at Umass Lowell. I emailed Alpha Analytical testing. I called and emailed the playground manufacturer. I Googled and searched until I was eventually referred to speak with Dr. Harari Homero, assistant professor in the Department of Environmental Medicine and Public Health at Mount Sinai. To my surprise, Dr. Homero emailed me back within two days, and by the end of the week, we were on a Zoom call.
Dr. Homero greeted me with gentle and kind fatigue, one I would soon realize had nothing to do with the fact that it was Friday at 4:30 p.m. I gave him an overview of the situation, and he took a deep breath, as if I was already testing his patience, before stating, “Yes, I could test your samples, but it wouldn’t do you any good.”
He shook his head, “We have to be ashamed; we should be embarrassed. As scientists in this field, we spend years trying to prove the obvious.”
He explained that my call is just one of the dozens he receives from working parents and underfunded nonprofits who spend countless hours trying to do the research and convince their communities that the material is questionable. They do not want their children “running around and playing on chopped-up tires like lab mice.”
He has stopped analyzing samples because the outcome will remain the same. The material contains lead, whether it’s within the FDA-approved exposure limit or a hotspot with elevated levels. The analysis of the material will reveal chemicals that are harmful to our environment and health.
“It is a conversation problem, not a science problem,” he said firmly. “Communities should be saying to industry, ‘prove to me it’s safe. Why do we have to prove to you it’s safe?’”
We do not know conclusively if the PIP and synthetic turf we install will give our kids cancer and poison our drinking water forever. We don’t know whether the material in my office closet would show elevated levels of dangerous chemicals, or whether the two feet of material next to it would have. We do know that harmful chemicals are present and have known long-term effects. I asked Dr. Homero, “Why don’t we just say no to this stuff then? Why is it even a conversation?”
He responded, “Industry will always put communities in a reactive state.”
Looking back on the West Tisbury schools’ experience, alongside the nine-year saga of the high school’s synthetic turf war, the Vineyard feels like the reactive spotlight Dr. Homero is referring to. Under pressure, in fight or flight, across many issues. These debates have cost us financially and environmentally. We can only hope it hasn’t threatened the health of our community.
When I look at the hunk of expensive rubber trash in my closet, I see an opportunity to reimagine our approach to environmental conversations and decisions on this Island. Since the debate, some towns have passed bylaws banning the installation of synthetic turf and other synthetic surfaces, and the redesign of our new high school promises an outdoor grass field. This is progress, but I still question whether it really needed to take us this long and use so many resources to reach that decision. What if, from the beginning, we all agreed that unless an industry can provide conclusive evidence of what is in their product and that it will not harm our children or our environment, we will not purchase, use or install it?
If we agreed on this and the importance of protecting our single-source aquifer, our soil and air and the health of our kids, we wouldn’t have to debate big decisions like the use of artificial turf and synthetic surfaces for years on end. Instead, we could all have gone outside and played with our kids on grass fields. It would have been a better use of our time.
Zada Clarke is the director of advocacy for the Vineyard Conservation Society. She lives in Chilmark.
This article appears in June 26, 2026.

Thank you, Zada!
Nice article. Not really relevant on island anymore. There are no surface twists to discuss. Why use a picture of a grass field. Very deceptive. Unless of course you are willing to go after the monstrosity of plastic over the single source aquifer just down the road from the high school (see nursery) or if you are willing to test the outputs from all those composters that make everyone feel good before you spread those delicious pfas laden materials on all our gardens. Let’s have the full conversation. Not just this one narrative.
Thank you, Zada, for this in-depth analysis. Very troubling.