tj_brookside_farm_stonewall
- Tim Johnson

On Memorial Day weekend 1972, when I was 10 years old, I got lost in the Chilmark woods. I was exploring near my family’s house on Fulling Mill Road, got turned around, and wandered west into an area that was undeveloped, and where thick woods had grown up on what had been pasture land into the 1930s. 

At a certain point I got scared but still thought I could find my way home. And then, in an especially dense section of the woods, I came across a ruined house: a stone foundation, a brick chimney, some other brickwork. I nearly fell into the open basement, and then I did get very scared—it seemed like a haunted house to me. 

I screamed, but no one seemed to hear me, so I plunged on into the woods. At one point I crossed a small stream and lost a sneaker in it. But eventually I calmed down and found my way home. Later that summer my father took me to the location of the ruined house, walking with me down a trail to South Road, so I could “conquer my fear” of the woods. I didn’t really have any fear, but it was nice to go walking with him. Close to South Road, we passed a teepee that some long-haired hippies were living in (this was 1972, after all).

Over time, the woods changed. In the 1990s the family which had owned the 70 acres to the west of Fulling Mill Road, including the ruined house, left 49 acres to be kept undeveloped in perpetuity, and divided the rest into seven lots along a new road, Henry Hough Lane. One of the lots was sold to two families, who built a large double home on it. It was only a couple of hundred feet from where my parents were still spending every summer. My father had unwisely sited our house just a few feet from the property line, to get a better view of the ocean (which disappeared from sight anyway, as the woods grew up). Now he paid for the decision, with the two families close enough that he could hear them talk, and for one of their lights to shine straight into his bedroom window at night. He called the families frequently to complain. Alas, the New York Times decided to do a story about the unusual double house and quoted one of the owners about the “irascible” neighbor who was always complaining. My father was appalled. 

Another house was built by a descendant of the original owners and her husband. Her family had bought the land in the 1920s from a Cornelius Lothrop, after his house burned down, with its ruins left to decay as the woods grew up. And, to my great surprise and pleasure, the new house, a gorgeous one, is the one my wife and I are renting this summer. At some point a bad storm knocked down more than 50 trees on the property. The owners had them uprooted and removed, so now the ruins of the old Lothrop house stand in the middle of a lovely meadow, which I am looking at as I type this. 

Everything comes full circle, and the house that so scared me is now almost a piece of lovely installation art.

David A. Bell is Professor of History at Princeton University, and is a frequent visitor the Vineyard. 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *