Recently, the Gazette published an article on the Copeland Plan review committee’s decision to deny the Ocean View Hotel proposal. I say bravo to Copeland Plan review committee! The proposal should never have been approved by MVC.

Oak Bluffs voters approved a bylaw that prohibits obstructing views from abutting properties. The hearings concluded that the proposal would clearly obstruct views. The MVC determined that this bylaw should not apply to Copeland’s narrow purview. I can accept that. But it is an absurd argument that the MVC can entirely ignore the bylaw in its deliberations because Copeland could not use the bylaw as a criterion.

The argument is particularly nonsensical after the MVC specifically discussed at one hearing that the commission can impose restrictions greater than a town’s restrictions, but they can’t impose restrictions that are less restrictive than a town’s. I’m certain that every voter that approved the bylaw believed that the bylaw should apply to all of Oak Bluffs and not exclude a District of Critical Planning Concern. 

Thankfully, Copeland corrected this illogical thinking by the MVC using criteria that were within Copeland’s purview, notably size and massing. Copeland therefore upheld the will of Oak Bluffs voters. I hope that in the future, the MVC and building commissioners will honor the will of the Oak Bluffs voters as well as all Island town voters.

Robert Clancy 

Oak Bluffs

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *