re_mvrhs_building_tour_cafeteria_032326_031
Students and teachers at the high school say the building doesn't get a passing grade. - Ray Ewing

The Islandwide vote on the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School renovation and addition — the largest public construction project in Island history — is less than three weeks away. On June 2, Vineyard residents will weigh in on the future of the school, which was designed during the administration of President Dwight D. Eisenhower and opened in 1959.

Many of those most directly affected by the decision, students currently attending the regional high school and the Island’s elementary schools, will not be able to take part in the process because they’re too young to vote. But some students do have strong opinions on the subject, along with another group that has a lot at stake: high school teachers and administrators.

To find out what it’s like for the people who spend five days a week inside the school, the Gazette recently held two round-table interviews at the school library, speaking first with teachers and department heads and then with six seniors who are preparing to graduate after four years.

Both groups said the 67-year-old school, with its obsolete mechanical systems, failing roof and substandard classrooms, makes everyday education a challenge for students and teachers alike.

On cold winter days some teachers plug in their own electric space heaters to keep their classrooms warm, said history teacher and social studies department head Ena Thulin. At the same time, students and teachers in other rooms often swelter in uncontrollable temperatures from an antiquated heating and cooling system that stopped providing reliable service years ago.

“It gets really hot,” senior Aiden Olsen said.

“People are always complaining about it,” he said, recalling his time in a classroom where the windows couldn’t be opened at any time of year.

“You’d just be sweating. It’s just distracting,” Mr. Olsen said.

The corridors no longer have any heat at all, other seniors said.

“The second you walk out of a classroom that has heat, it’s just freezing cold,” said Lily Fisher, 18, adding that the heating system wasn’t working in classrooms, either, on a cool late-April day.

“It definitely does get distracting when you’re sitting there and just, like, can’t stop shaking,” Ms. Fisher said.

The aging infrastructure also triggers fire alarms and building evacuations that take hours out of the school day, senior Bella Webster, 18, said.

“We’ve had a few over the years, but this year it’s been a lot more,” she said.

One of the alarms originated in a boiler room control panel that sparked flames and smoke, principal Sean Mulvey said. The emergency drew fire trucks and even helicopters circling overhead, while students were forced to miss their lunch period before returning to class more than an hour later, Ms. Webster said.

“It was a huge thing,” she said.

Although the average class at Martha’s Vineyard Regional has only about 20 students, teachers said they often struggle to move around their crowded rooms, which are far smaller than current state educational codes require.

Career and technical education, which prepares students for the workforce (a key function of the comprehensive high school), also takes place in substandard surroundings.

“Health assisting is our biggest problem [because] it’s such a small space that we can only do clinical observations with eight students, so that limits the amount of students we can have in the program,” said career and technical education department chair Jack O’Malley.

The health assisting course makes it possible for teenagers to earn their certificates as nursing assistants, but Ms. Webster, who took the class, said even as few as eight students can overwhelm the room.

“We had no space to do any of our practices on the mannequins [and] it was so hard to cram everyone in, trying to do our clinicals,” Ms. Webster said.

The space crunch also makes it hard for teachers to create an immersive learning experience for their students, said Spanish teacher and world languages department chair Erin Slossberg.

“When you’re teaching a world language, it is the idea of making the language come alive within the space. And when you have shared spaces with multiple languages… it limits the ability to create that dynamic surrounding environment,” she said.

Ms. Slossberg also lamented the lack of space for teacher collaboration.

“I don’t see members of my department for days [and] it feels so hard to connect and engage with your colleagues, which is such a detriment to how rich it could be if we could connect and share,” she said. 

“The physical nature of the building really, really impedes that richness,” Ms. Slossberg said.

Teachers and students pointed to the faulty electric systems throughout the school as both a distraction and a danger.

“You have whole walls with no outlets. You have outlets that don’t work anymore,” Ms. Thulin said. “It’s not uncommon in our school to have power strips connected to power strips connected to power strips, just so kids and teachers can plug computers in.”

Music teacher and performing arts chair Abigail Chandler said all the outlets in her classroom are faulty.

“Every time you plug something in… it eventually falls out, so I have lights flashing all the time,” said Ms. Chandler, who needs the lights because her classroom has no windows.

Another obstacle to learning, students said, comes straight through the walls.

“If you’re in one classroom, you can hear everything that’s going on in the classroom next to you,” senior Eleanor Mone said.

“It distracts everyone else, because you can’t focus on your teacher,” Ms. Mone said.

Her English teacher plays white noise in the background in an effort to cancel out sounds from outside the classroom, Ms. Mone said.

Students said they get distracted by other environmental noise as well, from a colony of chirping crickets under the floors — attributed by legend to a long-ago senior prank — to the footsteps of workers on the leak-prone roof.

Something also scrabbles around above the ceiling, Ms. Thulin said.

“There are definitely some critters upstairs,” she said.

Then there are the peculiar sounds emitted by the building itself. Ms. Webster and senior Tripp Arciaga, 17, described one of the unexplained noises that interrupted a class they shared this year.

“It slowly and slowly just got louder and louder and then just, like, ended,” Ms. Webster said, with exasperation.

“It sounded like in the cartoons, when someone falls off a cliff,” Mr. Arciaga said, laughing.

Science teacher and department head Louis Hall said all these distractions create real obstacles to learning, particularly for students with disabilities.

“Having a classroom that is in the high 80s and asking a kid to sit still and learn about genetics can be complicated,” he said. “Imagine going to your job where it is really either very cold and you need a jacket, or it’s really hot and you’re supposed to sit still.”

It all adds up to a flawed educational experience for students, Ms. Webster said.

“You can’t learn if there’s so many other things going on. It just makes it really hard,” she said. “If you want kids to have good learning, you need a good learning space.” 

As the vote date nears, the high school is continuing to open its doors for tours of the building on Wednesday nights and Saturday afternoons. An Islandwide information session on Zoom is planned for May 18 at 5:30 p.m., with details posted on the building project website, mvrhsbuildingproject.info.

An in-person information session is also scheduled for May 28 at 4:30 p.m. in the West Tisbury Free Public Library community room.

Join the Conversation

28 Comments

  1. There needs to be balance 400 million is out of balance. The school certainly needs work. I don’t think anyone can deny that. At the same time, the scale and cost of this project is out of balance with the budgets of the people who are expected to pay for it. As much as I would like to, unfortunately I won’t be able to support it because I need to be able to stay in my home.

    1. This is exactly what people said from Vineyard Haven when they voted down the new school build which was also needed… they could’ve only paid $20m & ended up paying $85m.

      We will only get the opportunity to get a grant like this once. Pass it by & the cost to build in a few years will continue to skyrocket. Tax payers also are already a couple million dollars on the hook after paying for engineering plans.

      This is the largest building on the island, accommodating children from all towns. If we want to ensure families stay here we need to create a suitable environment to educate their children. 800 students pass through these walls each year. They’re the future of this island. We should treat the building like it’s the keystone of our community instead of a burden. The YMCA alone is an $80m renovation. Firehouses and police stations all across the island are renovated to the tune of many many tens of millions if not collectively hundreds of millions. This pales in comparison to the scale of what the high school supports for student services. The school is responsible for creating the future doctors, police, teachers, firemen, business owners, & tradespeople that will build the real future of our island. That shared experience of going through high school at MVRHS is unique. What the high school offers is even more so. MVRHS serves the whole island.

      Fixed income voters & manipulative select people should carefully study their arguments about Tisbury’s cost & what ultimately happened as a result of passing it up. If Tisbury 2.0 happens the financial pain across the island will be without parallel.

  2. Every dollar spent on infrastructure along with the long term running costs that will accompany that infrastructure is money that will not go to actually educating our young people. Any analysis of birth rates will show declining student populations, add to this the all ready high island taxes and overall unsustainable cost of living for working families argues that spending hundreds of millions on a building is irresponsible. I’d go so far as to call it a monument to our own stupidity. We need a common sense plan to refurbish what we already have, as if it were our own family home.

    1. Please go buy a comparable value home elsewhere in Massachusetts with ready access to the ocean and then tell me about taxes. People on island have some fantasy that taxes are so low off island. It just is not true. As for declining enrollment. Where is this from. The more housing that keeps getting approved the more babies we will have.
      I assume nobody knows what a refurb costs. It’s on the school website. Summary. You lose state money. It takes longer. You rent and use trailers and you end up with the same poorly designed structure. That project does not exist. You would start over. New committee, new project definitions and all in future inflated $$$$. Just ask Tisbury how that worked out. 34M after state aid. 82M in the end. That 48M would have covered the bulk of Tisbury share of this project. I hope history does not repeat itself.

    2. I completely agree.
      What has the budget for maintenance been over the last years? If the heating and cooling system hasn’t “worked for years” why wasn’t it fixed or new installed? Fire in the boiler room, who is maintaining the school ? no plugs in the classrooms sounds like something that could be taken care of?
      The maintenance of the Tisbury school was also ignored, but committees were formed money is spent on studies and architects, etc. and with the mindset of a future new school why bother, in fact, the decrepit state helps the case. that it’s unfixable and only new is possible.

  3. VOTE NO! 400 million buys a lot of fast ferries and school buses, send our kids to higher rated academic institutions and proper Technical schools. look up the districts accountability scores the past decade. We are failing our community based on our per pupil costs.
    https://reportcards.doe.mass.edu/2025/07000505

    1. Fast ferris instead of school busses???

      That will add at least 3 hours to many student’s school day and give the students only a couple hours to spend time with their families.

      And forget about after school activities…

  4. Why did we choose this option when we had an alternative option to do a full gut renovation of the building with a higher percent MSBA reimbursement for around $100 million less than this project currently costs? Divvied up, that $100 million would go along way to providing other things the Island needs, which we will now need to forego. Education spending is critical, but spending does not spell results at these levels. If this is voted down, and we had to do this without the $75 million dollar MSBA reimbursements we might still save $30 million off the current price tag. We should all be actively appealing to the MSBA to let us reconsider the renovation option.

    1. Nobody pays attention. The Reno/code update was ruled out because it did not meet the stated need in the MSBA application. They generally don’t give you money for a project that does not meet the application you sold them on. More misinformation to misdirect voters. A committee of 25 ruled that out because it would get rejected. Pretty simple stuff. As “Really” said above, You can go it alone like Tisbury did.

    2. This same thinking is what killed tisbury school project and cost the town an additional $60m.

      Not only that the select board was so absurdly dedicated to keeping its decrepit Brock walls and front door that it wound up insisting that the door facade remained… leading to a door leading to nowhere.

      A single floor building like MVRHS has a massive footprint and will always be less efficient and a continual waste of energy and money.

      We need to stop dealing with hypotheticals. We have the grant. We have the plan. If we push this off we will end up with a higher price tag due to inflation and rising cost of everything on this island.

  5. Protect island taxpayers, almost half a billion dollars for this project is outrageous. Think about all the tax increases and hardship that will fund this. Hard NO!

  6. wrong time to build a school. People are trying to survive the present administration. Gas is 5.79 today.

    1. The constant problem in the US is that infrastructure plans are always postponed or simply abandoned when the cheapest time to have made improvements is Now. Quit kicking the can down the road!

  7. Why would anyone give this kind of money to people in charge of a school that they let fall into such disrepair…That building can be repaired and last for another number of years….Our lives and education is going to change rapidly. Let’s wait and see what the next decade brings. There will be major changes to education that will need to be addressed in totally different ways. 400million is insane…

    1. The voters let it fall into disrepair. Annually the schools are asked to level fund. That comes from select boards, fincoms and town managers. With contractually negotiated increases to salaries and increasing insurance and energy cost, where does everyone think the crunch is. Hmmmmm building maintenance. This falls squarely in laps of voters who complain annually about the budget. Old adage. We reap what we sow.

  8. Vote yes! Complaining about the cost is laughable. Take a few minutes and research the costs of upcoming high school projects in Revere & Lexington. Everything is expensive, and, when you add in the cost of getting it to an island, it becomes more expensive. Voting it down now will only result in added future costs or funding it without MSBA help, like Tisbury.

  9. No one wants to face the fact that our public education system in this country is failing. It is failing our students. Our global standing is abysmal. Buildings do not educate, they house people. This insane amount of taxpayer dollars to build this school is an exercise in futility. Our students will not be better educated but people will feel better for throwing other people’s money at a pointless enterprise.

  10. Maybe if we look into a Chapter 74 new school that focuses on agro/science and the trades the state will view the project differently.
    * Agricultural Mechanics
    * Animal Science
    * Carpentry
    * Cabinetmaking
    * Automotive
    * HVAC
    * Welding
    * Electrical
    * Plumbing
    * Advanced Manufacturing
    * Horticulture
    * Culinary
    * Marine mechanics

    Look at Shepaug Regional HS in CT.

    1. MVRHS is a Chapter 74 school with seven vocational/technical programs. I’m sure that if there were more space and qualified teaching staff, there would be more.

      MVRHS is also a comprehensive high school that regularly graduates students who attend Ivy League universities, as well as competitive vocational/technical and art schools. Additionally, MVRHS offers an alternative education path, a social-emotional program, and a high-needs program for students up to age 21.

      The building also houses year-round adult education programming and island-wide performing arts center events.

      It is a lot of things to a lot of different people all rolled into one crumbling, poorly insulated, substandard, failing building.

  11. Please stop gaslighting the public on everything to do with the school. Parts of it are 67 years old a good deal of it is maybe 25 years old. Every article I read tends to put a spin on it that we need to have a brand new building.

    1. Good thing the project is outlined as a renovation of the newer part of the building, built in the mid to late 90s. The guts and infrastructure (electrical, HVAC, etc.) and older parts built in the 80s and 50s need far more work and are slated for demo. The new construction includes a library, a cafeteria, and an academic wing that is up to code and meets educational standards. This is actually not even more classrooms than are currently at the school, just appropriately sized ones, making the square footage larger.

      Keep in mind that after MSBA reimbursement, the island is looking at about 250m, not 400m. This is on par with other school building projects across the state. A gut/reno of the building would not qualify for MSBA reimbursement and was roughly 230m…add the cost of trailers to house students for years, and it makes logical sense to do a reno/construction.

  12. I spent forty eight years in the trades thirty four years running my own company. I toured the structure with former facilities manager, Mike Taus. Maintenance can’t be done on wiring, plumbing, HVAC systems buried in the walls, old single pane windows, minimal insulation,
    The building has served it’s purpose, it is time to rebuild.
    The true question we need to face is are we going to chose our pocketbook over our children. A community that doesn’t care for it’s young and old has ceased to be. I am voting for our children, I am voting for the high school renovation.

    Terry Donaue

  13. It is so interesting to me that a recently built building is in such disrepair. We are asking taxpayers living in buildings built in the 1800’s, in many cases, to support a school system that either cannot, or will not, repair its buildings. What is the explanation for that?

    1. Hi Lorraine
      The houses people are living in built in the 1800’s have been renovated. If they weren’t you would be without electricity, indoor plumbing or central heating.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *