Who Owns Main Street, Edgartown

← Full story | Main Street, Edgartown | Circuit Avenue, Oak Bluffs | Main Street, Vineyard Haven

The map below, derived from the assessors’ map, shows the commercial properties that line a section of Edgartown's Main street running from the top of Pease Point Way to Dock street. The numbers on the map correspond to the street addresses as listed in assessors’ records. (In some cases, the numbers that appear on the buildings themselves differ from municipal records). For each property, we have tried to identify the current storefronts and businesses that occupy each building, the total assessed value of the property as of Jan. 1, 2023 (land plus buildings), the owner of record and, where the property is owned by a trust or corporation, the names of individuals associated with that entity according to state records.

North Side of Main street

2 Dock street

Current business occupant(s): MV Bike Rentals, Whatever Silver
Total assessed property value: $1,766,000
Property owner: Thor Peterson

8 Mayhew

Current business occupant(s): The Wharf
Total assessed property value: $6,699,500
Property owner: Wharf Holdings (Brian Navarro)

19 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Black Dog Store
Total assessed property value: $5,245,500
Property owner: Charles Hajjar

25 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Edgartown Paper Store
Total assessed property value: $2,585,800
Property owner: Barbara Courtney

29 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Island Outfitters
Total assessed property value: $1,620,200
Property owner: 29 Main LLC (Mairead MacClarence)

33 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Lily Pulitzer
Total assessed property value: $1,111,300
Property owner: 193 Worcester Road Assoc. (Gordon & Jonathan Russell)

37 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Sole
Total assessed property value: $2,839,800
Property owner: North Water Street Corp.

39 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Suka
Total assessed property value: $878,800
Property owner: HL 39 Main St. LLC (Laurence Scherzer)

41 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Nell
Total assessed property value: $2,483,300
Property owner: Jeid Island LLC (Sarah Levine)

47 Main street

Current business occupant(s): J. McLaughlin, Boneyard Surf Shop
Total assessed property value: $3,087,200
Property owner: Benjamin & Brian Hall

53 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Claudia Jewelry, Rochelle’s
Total assessed property value: $3,008,300
Property owner: Benjamin & Brian Hall

55 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Port Hunter
Total assessed property value: $3,289,000
Property owner: Benjamin & Brian Hall

61 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Shirt Tales
Total assessed property value: $4,273,300
Property owner: Barbara Courtney

65 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Edgartown Cinemas, Edgartown Diner, Charleston Shoe Co., Rosewater Spirits
Total assessed property value: $5,707,500
Property owner: Barbara & Eugene Courtney

71 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Alchemy
Total assessed property value: $5,084,900
Property owner: A on Main Real Estate LLC (Todd A. Dagres)

81 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Court House
Total assessed property value: $5,084,900
Property owner: County of Dukes County

89 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Old Whaling Church
Total assessed property value: $5,365,800
Property owner: Vineyard Preservation Trust

99 Main street

Current business occupant(s): Dr. Daniel Fisher house
Total assessed property value: $6,297,300
Property owner: Vineyard Preservation Trust

South Side of Main street

2 Main street

Current business occupant(s): The Atlantic
Total assessed property value: $10,343,600
Property owner: Main St. LLC (Gerret Conover, Dan Stanton)

7 South Water street

Current business occupant(s): Harborside Inn, Backwater Trading, Respoke, CB Stark
Total assessed property value: $25,645,800
Property owner: Harborside Condominium Trust