Birds are changing their winter ranges as a result of climate change. Average temperatures in January have increased more than five degrees Fahrenheit in the continental United States between 1966 and 2005, and the ranges of many species of birds in the early winter have shifted northward.
Scientists at the National Audubon Society analyzed the results of Christmas Bird Count data between 1966 and 2005. Of the 305 species that were widespread enough to be studied, 177 species (58 per cent) had their ranges move northward. More than 60 of these species had their ranges move northward by more than 100 miles in those 40 years. Seventy-nine species (26 per cent) had their ranges move southward, and the trends were not statistically significant for the remaining 49 species (16 per cent). These results are consistent with the global warming hypothesis; the majority of species shifted northward and the shifts were greater in areas with the greatest warming.
Land birds showed the greatest shift; 64 per cent of these species moved northward, with an average shift of almost 50 miles. Almost half (46 per cent) of the coastal species moved northward, with an average northward shift of about 20 miles. And almost half (52 per cent) of the waterbirds moved northward, with an average change of about 15 miles northward.
Range shifts away from the coast were found for twice as many species as had their ranges shift toward the coast. This is consistent with global warming since higher temperatures inland might translate into greater food availability due to less frozen ground and more open water.
Other explanations may contribute to these shifts but they do not explain these changes as well as does global warming. These results are not consistent with known increases or decreases in bird populations. And bird feeding does not explain the northward shifts in the many woodland and water bird species that do not utilize this supplemental food source. Habitat changes do not explain these changes either.
Here are some of the highlights relative to species commonly found on our local Christmas Bird Count. The following list shows how many miles each species range has shifted; a positive number indicates a northward shift and a negative number indicates a southward shift.
brant 193 miles
Canada goose 120
mute swan -123
gadwall 149
American black duck 182
greater scaup -136
surf scoter -47
white-winged scoter 130
black scoter -233
bufflehead -267
hooded merganser -93
red-breasted merganser 317
red-throated loon -277
common loon -95
northern gannet 83
double-crested cormorant 117
great cormorant -25
turkey vulture 53
northern harrier 77
American kestrel 54
black-bellied plover 114
killdeer -78
sanderling -169
herring gull 24
great black-backed gull -24
mourning dove 147
belted kingfisher 98
red-bellied woodpecker 60
northern flicker 192
blue jay 89
American crow 89
black-capped chickadee 90
red-breasted nuthatch 244
Carolina wren 57
eastern bluebird 114
European starling 86
cedar waxwing 189
rufous-sided towhee 215
song sparrow 74
white-throated sparrow 109
dark-eyed junco 116
purple finch 433
house finch 270
American goldfinch 219
house sparrow 77
So what can we conclude? Certainly bird distributions are changing. Northward changes are twice as common as are southward changes, which may be due to the observed five degrees Fahrenheit increase in the average temperatures in January. These are the impacts of climate change in the past 40 years, so how much will they change in the future? What other changes are occurring?
Whether these observed temperature changes are due to people and the increased levels of carbon in our atmosphere is another topic that will not be debated here. But this study can serve as a canary in the coal mine that documents and warns us of ongoing environmental changes.
Comments
Comment policy »