Edgartown firefighters are investigating the cause of a fire that burned down a Chappaquiddick home in the early hours of Thursday morning.

Firefighters received a call reporting the house at 123 Litchfield Road was on fire at 2 a.m. After firefighters on Chappy saw the extent of the blaze, the department sent out calls for aid to neighboring departments.
The house was deemed a total loss, and crews worked to extinguish the fire before it spread to the nearby woods, the department wrote in a statement on Facebook.
No one was injured and the occupants of the home were able to make it out safely, the department wrote. In a statement, fire Chief Alex Schaeffer said that a woman and her dog were able to get out safely after being alerted by the smoke detectors.
The fire triggered an extensive response from Island fire departments. On-call firefighters on Chappaquiddick were the first to arrive. Other firefighters staged at Edgartown Memorial Wharf and worked with the Chappy Ferry to shuttle personnel and equipment across the channel, according to Edgartown’s statement.
Fire crews used a new cistern on Chappaquiddick Road and shuttled water over with the help of two tankers.
After firefighters doused the flames, a team was assigned to stand watch to make sure the fire didn’t reignite.
Edgartown did not say what caused the fire. Chief of police Chris Dolby confirmed the address.
The fire department did thank Oak Bluffs, Tisbury and West Tisbury for providing aid, and the Chappy Ferry for helping with transportation.
According to assessor records, the home belongs to Michael Coffey and Kathleen Nagle.
“Please keep the homeowners in your hearts as they process this news,” the Edgartown department wrote.
This article appears in June 12, 2026.
