Aimee Cotton Indicted on Murder Charge

A Dukes County grand jury returned indictments of murder and reckless endangerment of a child for Aimee Cotton, the Oak Bluffs babysitter who allegedly left two-year-old Frank Rodenbaugh in her SUV alone.

Read More

Aimee Cotton Case to Move Off Island

Dukes County Superior Court Judge Peter Krupp said Wednesday that he would allow Aimee Cotton’s case to move to the superior court in Barnstable for trial after her lawyer raised concerns about the chances of an impartial jury on Martha's Vineyard.

Read More

Wrongful Death Suit Put on Pause

The civil lawsuit against Aimee Cotton for the wrongful death of a child who had been in her care is on hold while her criminal case unfolds in court.

Read More

Neighbor Files Lawsuit Over Oakwood Development Plan

A Circuit avenue building owner is suing the Martha’s Vineyard Commission over the regional planning agency’s decision in favor of a new project at the former Phillips Hardware site. 

Read More

Edgartown Man Pleads Guilty in SSA Bomb Threat Case

David Capato, who staged a bomb threat at the Vineyard Haven Steamship Authority terminal in 2025, pleaded guilty to several charges in court this week but will not face any jail time. 

Read More

Judge Dismisses South Water Street Home Lawsuit

A neighbor’s complaint against a controversial home expansion in Edgartown was tossed out by a Dukes County Superior Court judge this week. 

Read More

Rodenbaugh Family Raises Concerns About Court Case

A Dukes County Superior Court judge this week declined to impose a curfew against a babysitter who is awaiting a trial for manslaughter, frustrating the family of the alleged victim who felt the prosecution could be doing more in the case.

Read More

West Tisbury Cop Sues Over Chief Hiring Process

A West Tisbury police lieutenant who was passed over for a promotion is claiming he was retaliated against for his union activities and wasn’t offered the chief’s position because he wouldn’t accept a quid pro quo agreement.

Read More

Babysitter Sued Over Child’s Death

The parents of Frank Rodenbaugh filed a wrongful death suit in Dukes County Superior Court last week against the toddler's babysitter Aimee Cotton.

Read More

Judge Hears Arguments in Lampost Housing Case

Windsor Circuit, Ltd. owner of the building that formerly housed multi-story Circuit avenue bar and nightclub The Lampost, is seeking to overturn a 2022 MVC decision that denied the company’s request to reduce the number of restricted workforce housing units in what used to be the bar’s upper three floors.

Read More

Pages